By Oscar de la Torre Santa Monica
I am dismayed at this paper’s attempt to discredit the work that I have done to expand safety to Santa Monica’s schools, community and youth (SMDP, Aug. 5, page 1). Your front page headline titled “bad behavior” is misleading and disrespectful. From reading your headline and the angle of your story it seems to me that the Santa Monica Daily Press would like to blame me for the violence that erupted on Samohi’s campus on April 15, 2005. This is an outrage in light of all of the work I continue to do to ensure that our youth live in a peaceful community. To create a peaceful community we need to avoid disrespecting people, negative labeling and stereotypes. This behavior is not non-violence. This form of non-physical violence is just as hurtful and only contributes to ill feelings. As I have done in the past, I call on all of us to come from a position of mutual respect.
Let us not forget that the “bad behavior” of students was one major cause of the violence that erupted on April 15 at Santa Monica High. Although a small number of students were involved in the fights, many students disobeyed the administrators when told to disperse. It was your paper that then racialized the incident by stating that “no white students were involved.” This is incorrect, as many students of all colors disobeyed, resulting in the police being called on to campus. Why the students disobeyed administrators is a whole other story and if the fights could have been prevented in the first place is another story that I am in the process of assessing.
My visit on April 21 to Samohi’s campus was peaceful, and there was no indication that a “riot” could have taken place. In fact, we talked to Latino and African American youth without incident. I do not want readers to get the impression that I played a role in the violence that occurred on April 15. I submitted a letter to the editor explaining my role in the incident, but Ryan Hyatt conveniently decided to ignore this important information when he wrote his story on Aug. 4. On a similar note, I want to clarify the statement that was misconstrued by Ryan — I never stated that I was planning to bring “ex-gang members” to campus in the future. In the past, I have brought guest speakers that have something positive to contribute to students and our schools.
For example, in June 2005 I brought a successful businessman named Fernando Espuelas, owner of VOY entertainment, to be the keynote speaker during Samohi’s peace rally. Interestingly enough, the press did not even care to cover the story. So if students are in conflict, it is a newsworthy story; if students rally for peace, it is a non-story. And a similar media strategy applies to my actions. This is a sad reality. What role then does the press have in perpetuating youth violence, and more importantly racializing the violence as black versus brown? Does any other racial group or institution share any responsibility for the disturbance that occurred on April 15? I participated in mediation efforts on April 15 and every day after, and students at Samohi had a lot to say about the disconnect they experience on campus and the need for a curriculum that expands cross-cultural understanding.
I do believe that what happened on April 15 is an important event that should not be trivialized by any other residual conflict that came from it. We should be asking ourselves, what is the root cause of the violence? More importantly, what has the school district done to prevent this type of violence in the future to keep our school safe? I have proposed a hate-crime enhancement policy to expand disciplinary measures for students who engage in racially motivated violence. State law prohibits local school districts from implementing a zero-tolerance policy, but I am proposing that we take away the privileges of playing sports, attending our schools on permit or attending school functions for students who engage in racially motivated violence. In addition, we should have mandatory in-house suspensions that include inter-cultural training to attack the ignorance that lies at the foundation of this type of conflict.
There are many other solutions and actions that my colleagues on the school board have proposed and implemented, but the Santa Monica Daily Press seems to not be interested in informing the public about this. In addition, I feel that the Unity Coalition has developed the most comprehensive plan to address this problem at the root, and I look forward to working with their proposals in the future. I sincerely hope that we can move forward on solutions and not distract from the real problems that affect our schools and students. It is a disservice to the community for the Santa Monica Daily Press to attack anyone with biased stories and sell them as news to the public. We need to model the respect we want our youth to have for each other.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 10, 2005. Read the original PDF.