By GUEST COMMENTARY BY DONNA J. WARREN
The president’s convention speech last night makes it clear that the final months of the 2004 presidential election will be fought on the wisdom and implementation of President Bush’s “doctrine of preemption,” which boils down to “getting the enemy before they get us.” Sen. John Kerry and his Democratic colleagues have not argued that the doctrine is wrong, but instead have argued over what is “an imminent threat.”
Surprisingly, the debate over preemp-tion isn’t limited to the war in Iraq or even to the broader war on terrorism. In fact, an identical debate over preemption is at the center of the candidate’s difference on Social Security. During his prime time convention speech, and in other speeches around the country, President Bush has argued that Social Security’s looming insolvency is an imminent threat to the economic security of tomorrow’s retirees. For this reason, he has called for preemptively overhauling Social Security by moving our nation’s retirement program from a pay-as-you go system, where current taxes pay for current retirees, to a partially pre-funded system where a portion of a worker’s Social Security taxes would be placed in personal investment accounts that would provide a nest egg to workers in their retirement. The balance of our Social Security taxes would continue to provide benefits to seniors who are already in or near retirement.
Sen. Kerry is not necessarily opposed to preemptive action on Social Security. In fact, in an appearance on NBC’s “Meet the Press” earlier this year, he admitted that in 1995, when he thought Social Security was going broke, he favored raising the retirement age and means testing Social Security benefits. Since that time, however, he has come to believe that Social Security is not in jeopardy and now believes that “economic growth” can delay any need for action. In fact, earlier this month, he noted that a “tweak here and a tweak there” can put Social Security on a sound footing for decades to come.
So, once again, the primary difference between the candidates on whether or not to take preemptive action boils down to their differing views of the threat that lies ahead. What does existing intelligence tell us about the threat of an unreformed Social Security?
A week ago, Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan gave the gravest and clearest warning yet. In a speech in Jackson Hole, Wyo., Greenspan pointed out the significant demographic changes our country has undergone. Due to the low fertility rates of American women and aging of the baby boom, we are faced with a dramatically growing elderly dependency ratio. Greenspan noted that this population shift will pose “substantial challenges” to Social Security, which he noted is already in a long term “chronic deficit.” His warning came with a caveat that while “stark choices” must be made in order to put Social Security on sound footing, that these changes if done sooner rather than later could stem the need for changes that would be both “abrupt and painful.”
Greenspan’s warning only adds to the chorus of alarms that have recently been sounded on the need to reform Social Security. On the issue of “imminent threat,” almost every independent and non-partisan organization that has studied Social Security has come to the same conclusion: The shrinking worker to retiree ratio is putting Social Security’s finances in jeopardy. Within two decades, Social Security will be running substantial deficits that will eat away at the security of future retirees, and will put significant strains on the tax burdens of future workers. In short, Social Security is on a certain path to insolvency — a path that can only be changed by immediate and decisive action.
To counter the looming deficits and mounting taxes that constitute Social Security’s twin threat will require a president willing to put his reputation and legacy on the line — one who recognizes the danger and is willing to act despite severe short-term opposition. America’s future depends on electing a president that sees and understands this threat. (Derrick Max is the executive director of the Alliance for Worker Retirement Security, a broad-based coalition of 40 organizations representing large and small employers. He is available at).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 3, 2004. Read the original PDF.