By GUEST COMMENTARY BY ROB JUPILLE Business
You would think that as a Santa Monica-based financial planner and money manager, I would whole-heartedly endorse President Bush’s Social Security reform proposal. Despite the obvious benefit to fee-based planners like me, President Bush’s current proposal is a bad idea for one simple reason: The average American stinks at managing their equity investments.
President Bush’s controversial proposal provides workers with the opportunity to invest a portion of their Social Security taxes into self-directed retirement accounts. The premise is simple and, quite frankly, valid. By allowing individuals to invest a portion of their Social Security tax in the stock market, their returns over the long run should exceed what they would have earned had the money been invested in the Social Security system itself. Over time, this should allow the system to maintain its solvency beyond its current projection.
So, younger clients would be allowed to have some control over their retirement assets, and this should extend the likelihood that they will have some form of Social Security protection available to them at retirement. It also would provide me with an opportunity to assist them in investing in privatized funds — at my regular fee, of course.
You’d think I’d love this plan, but there’s one problem, the “shoulds” don’t pan out. You see, most individual investors just don’t increase their returns when they invest in the stock market.
A recent study by Dalbar, a Boston financial services research firm, found that from January 1984 to December 2000, a time generally regarded as one of the greatest bull markets ever, the S&P 500 averaged 16.29 percent per year. Unfortunately, the average U.S. equity investor earned a paltry 5.32 percent per year. That’s less than they would have earned in risk-free Treasury Bills during the same period. How is it that the average investor can perform so poorly during such a strong market? Simply put, their dramatic underperfor-mance can be tied to the misguided confidence they have in their ability to time the markets.
We drive this home with our clients all the time, but it bears repeating: Trying to time the market based on somebody’s best guess of its short-term direction is a fool’s game. Unfortunately, the typical individual investor does this continually when they hunt for the next hot stock fund. After reading numerous magazines with headlines such at “The 10 Best Funds to Buy Today,” and confident they’ve finally found the next hot thing, they buy. The problem is that by the time they pull the trigger and place the order, their “hot” fund has already peaked. Once it starts to decline, they bail out. The pattern is repeated time and again with the same result: Buying high and selling low. This is hardly a formula that will increase one’s Social Security benefits.
These same investors would be much better served by developing an asset allocation based on their individual time frame, retirement goals, and risk tolerance, only adjusting the mix as their personal circumstances change. This approach is neither exciting nor terribly sexy, but the fact is that this buy-and-hold, asset allocation strategy works.
According to Dalbar, “Mutual fund investors who practice a buy-and-hold strategy earn higher real investor returns than those who attempt to time the market.”
Traditionally, politicians have avoided the Social Security discussion like the plague, and President Bush’s focus on Social Security reform is a bold step in the right direction.
While we are by no means fans of government intrusion into our lives, the average investor has consistently shown an inability to match the performance of the market, let alone beat it. In order for Mr. Bush’s Social Security privatization proposal to work, it must come with restrictions that limit the self-destructive and emotional investment behavior that has caused investors’ sub-par performance, even during bull markets. By limiting both investor choices as well as imposing severe penalties for market-timing activity, a workable solution can be achieved. Until I see evidence of these restrictions, however, Social Security privatization is a bad idea. (Santa Monica-based financial planner Rob Jupille is the president of RTJ Financial Management, Inc.)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 17, 2005. Read the original PDF.