Skip to content

Spam e-mail and campaign finance law has nothing to do with First Amendment rights THINK

Published:

twice

By Todd Flora

So called First Amendment advocates cried foul last week over two major policy decisions. First, the Supreme Court upheld nearly all provisions of the federal McCain- Feingold campaign finance law, angering those that feel money in politics should equal free speech. Second, some complained that free speech was in danger when a law was enacted that put new regulations on those who fan unwanted junk e-mail all over cyberspace.

Those who claim either action threatens the free speech provisions of the First Amendment are dead wrong.

The development of unwanted Internet “spam” has threatened the vitality of Internet service providers, e-commerce and office productivity. Modest e-mail users are turned off by an e-mail inbox filled with offers of sketchy mortgages, cheap Viagara or breast enhancements, and pornography. These users don’t stay online long, and therefore don’t take full advantage of other aspects of communication and e-commerce that move the economy. What’s more, economists estimate that the collective workforce incurs major losses in productivity as they dance the delete button through relevant and unwanted e-mail.

But here’s the kicker in terms of the First Amendment: Spammers don’t let you communicate with THEM. At best, a link that seemingly allows users to unsubscribe merely alerts spammers that an e-mail address is active, and that address is then rented out or shared with other spammers. At worst, there is no inability to “speak back” to your offending spammer, as they often use dummy e-mail addresses with no response function. Where is the consumer allowed free speech in that transaction? Case closed.

In the political world, the airwaves are polluted by endless ads that ask “Congressmember so-and-so to stand up for seniors,” or “for crime victims,” or “the environment” — you name it — without actually asking viewers to vote for or against the representative in question or their opponent. These “issue ads” are thinly veiled campaign ads paid for by political parties, and despite the annoyance, will still be allowed under McCain-Feingold reform provisions. But you would never hear that from campaign finance opponents. They balk at the very fair and necessary provision that states 30 and 60 days before a primary and general election, respectively, that only ads paid for by direct donations to a candidate’s campaign would be permissible. They say such a practice infringes on free speech. I say — and the Supreme Court has ruled — that the public has a right to protect against lopsided distortions to democracy.

Reform foes who like to point to the famous 1976 “Buckley vs. Valeo” Supreme Court decision which barred spending caps in political campaigns selectively forget another important provision in the landmark decision. The Court also used “Buckley vs. Valeo” to affirm the public’s disgust with unlimited donations by single individuals to a particular candidate. The decision held that 1974 reforms limiting donations to $1,000 per election to federal candidates was justified given the clear and present danger to democracy presented by unregulated contributions from wealthy individuals, interests, and corporations. So, while no overall spending limit was approved for campaigns, contribution totals themselves were limited.

We have an equally clear and present danger to democracy in the unregulated “soft money” that the political parties use to fund these issue ads. Clearly the values affirmed by the Supreme Court can be applied to the proliferation of issue ads without destroying candidates, political parties, or the First Amendment.

I applaud those that wish to defend free speech. But my advice to you would be to focus on John Ashcroft, not toward responsible public policies that have curbed an abuse of speech. There is a matter of degree here. Those that criticize McCain-Feingold's limit on issue-ads make an earnest policy argument, while seedy spam artists have no leg to stand on. At the end of the day, both are wrong, however, and should not hide behind a false banner of free speech in disparaging those that fight to reform our marketplace or political campaigns. (Todd Flora is a six-year resident of Santa Monica. He is a government relations representative with a statewide children’s network, and the former state director of the California Clean Money Campaign. To comment or reach Todd, ).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on December 16, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe