Skip to content

State and education will come up short without new revenue sources

Published:

By GUEST COMMENTARY BY YOLIE FLORES & BETH OSTHIMER

Each election cycle, political candidates declare their commitment to children and to families. They make promises, kiss babies, visit after-school programs, and use rhetoric in speeches that would lead one to believe that finally, we have a leader who really understands that investing in the health, education, and well-being of our children is not only the morally right thing to do, but a smart investment for our future as well. Fast forward to today, when these same individuals now have the opportunity to make their rhetoric a reality. What we see are our state and national leaders debating budget proposals that will leave the children of California less healthy, less educated, less financially secure, and burdened with debt. At the same time, our wealthiest residents are benefiting from unprecedented tax cuts, while more than 800,000 of California’s children lack health insurance coverage and more than 1.7 million live in poverty.

As our representatives aim to curb spending and plan for the future of our state, our children and our families, there are clearly better choices to be made, and some false choices that we must reject. False choices — like those which pit basic human service needs against education investments for our children. Or false choices that posit that the only “solution” to balance our budget is to cut funding for education and health care for our children, rather than explore new revenue solutions supported by the vast majority of Californians who want to make these needed investments Clearly, education must be a priority for our state. California is one of the largest states in the nation, yet we rank 29th in terms of per pupil spending and 79 percent of our fourth graders are reading below grade level. At the same time, our children need proper nutrition, good health, and a safe place to grow and thrive in order to learn. Under the proposed budget, the governor’s approach is to “save” the state $2 billion by passing on opportunities to invest in education rather than reinstating the top income tax brackets on our state’s wealthiest residents to help cover critical, needed investments in our children’s education, health and well-being.

Although the proposed budget doesn’t make indiscriminate cuts in all health and human service programs, it nonetheless represents a real danger to children and families. There is a fundamental lack of balance in the solutions this budget seeks. Our children and their families already are facing a crisis of poverty, which continues to escalate as the state’s high housing costs continue to soar. The latest reports indicate that a minimum household income of more than $120,000 is needed to purchase a median-priced home in California, placing decent, safe housing out of the reach of working families in our state.

There are other, better choices for our children. Rather than reducing CalWORKs grants that help the state’s lowest income families buy food, shelter and clothing to “save” $159 million, the state could raise $230 to $380 million by limiting excessive corporate tax credits. Rather than imposing health insurance premiums on low-income families that are expected to result in children losing health coverage, “saving” $43 million beginning in 2007, the state could adopt a reasonable sales tax on entertainment-related businesses such as golf courses and ski resorts, which could raise revenues by $1.2 billion. Our children and families are certainly worthy of such a small investment of our recreational spending.

No one doubts that sacrifices will need to be made to ensure our state’s long-term financial success. But that responsibility should be shared, and should not primarily fall on the shoulders of California’s children and struggling families. We must hold our elected officials to their commitments and insist that our state make cost-effective, proven investments in our children and our future. New revenue sources must be part of any equation for solving our state’s long-term budget crisis. (Flores is executive director of Los Angeles County Children’s Planning Council. Osthimer is state director of the Children’s Defense Fund California.)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 28, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe