By Todd Flora
The state budget mess is a staggering policy calamity that will require spending cuts AND tax increases. I don’t care who’s fault the budget deficit is, or how silly a few million in “pork projects” look. With a near $35 million shortfall, no one can credibly argue that our problems can be solved without SOME tax increases AND budget cuts we won’t enjoy. It is not a time for ideological blinders — only for tough choices and shared pain.
The facts are these: You could shut down many vital services and K–college education in this state and still fall short. How strong a suggestion do we need to raise revenue in addition to cutting spending? Yet Republican leaders threaten retribution against any GOP legislator who votes for higher taxes. What may be worse than this ideological hubris is the Republicans’ insistence that we pass the buck by floating the deficit over the next few annual budgets. Isn’t this the kind of wimpy lack of leadership Washington usually delivers? This will delay problems, not solve them.
California’s elected leaders must also use this time to restructure how we raise revenue in the post-Proposition 13 era. Assemblymember Darrell Steinberg (D-Sacramento) sponsored a bill that would have launched a pilot project in Sacramento and surrounding counties. The project would test revenue enhancements that will allow those localities to wean themselves from growing and developing by way of “big box” stores, outlet malls, and car dealerships — the overused but obvious option for many localities who must make up for lost tax revenue since Proposition 13’s passage in 1978. And OK — I’ll say it — we must reconsider Proposition 13 and restructure property taxes for a growing California population. Assemblymember Steinberg’s model would be a good start.
With a $35 BILLION deficit, this is no time for clever grandstanding. Tell your state representatives you want tough choices made, and that you are willing to take the pain so long as it is shared, quick, and effective.
Todd Flora is the former state director of the California Clean Money Campaign, a campaign finance reform effort, and the former Western regional director of the Concord Coalition, a fiscal watchdog organization. To respond or to reach Todd,
Top 6 budget items Gov. Gray Davis Should reduce before raising taxes
Have you ever wondered why those mean Republicans always refer to us as “tax and spend Democrats?”
As California faces a multi-billion dollar budget shortfall, the governor and legislature ponder raising taxes.
Why not look for ways to spend less, instead of asking taxpayers to pay more? I’ve highlighted some not-quite-untouchable items in California’s budget:
6. $1 billion each year goes to the Department of Child Support Services — a department created solely to collect child support from deadbeat parents. A third of this budget goes towards collecting child support from California parents for children in other states. Maybe we should seek reimbursement from those other states.
About 15 percent of this $1 billion budget is a penalty to the feds, because California has not implemented a statewide, automated child support system, as mandated by federal law. We’re paying for our lack of efficiency – literally and figuratively.
5. California spent $5 billion last year for 142 transportation projects to “relieve traffic congestion.” Do you think that traffic is $5 billion less congested? Where are those 142 projects, and why don’t they relieve congestion near me?
4. Nearly $6 million was spent last year for “increased functionality” of the state Web site, www.ca.gov. The budget summary says the Web site allows 2.6 million web visitors per day to “reserve a state park campsite, register an automobile, apply for a professional license, check road conditions, apply for a job...” What else does it need to do?
3. California shelled out $3 million for nuclear weapon detection devices on the Mexican border. If this doesn’t scream “federal reimbursement,” I don’t know what does.
2. We spent $2.554 million last year on postage increases for the DMV alone. It was a 3 cent increase, in case you forgot, so that means the DMV sent out 84.28 million pieces of mail this year? How many cars and/or drivers do we have? Is Arthur Anderson doing the DMV’s accounting?
And the No. 1 item the Governor and legislature can cut from our state budget instead of raising our taxes...
1. The Mobilehome Purchase Fund.
Need I say more?
Feel free to send this to your state assemblymember and/or state senator — that’s who’ll decide if we pay more taxes next year. Common sense says if you have less, you spend less. I hope they will do some belt-tightening before asking us to empty our pockets.
(Evelyn Jerome is a past president of the Los Angeles County Young Democrats, and a member of the New Democrat Network. To respond or to reach Jerome, )
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on December 31, 2002. Read the original PDF.