By RON SCOTT SMITH
Since last night’s final Bush-Kerry debate finished well beyond bedtime for this newspaper’s page 4, I sat here on the eve of the thing, staring at a blank document, unable to comment on results, left only to prognosticate. I would have told you to take Kerry and give the points if I could have gotten to you in time.
The focus was “domestic issues,” and I ask you to count the number of times the president might have used the word “liberal” in an attempt to berate his opponent, as if calling him a dirty name.
A favorite book written by somebody named Webster, defines “liberal” as “marked by generosity,” while it defines “conservative” as “marked by caution.” So choose your mark.
I don’t know about you, but I kind of like public libraries. My son checked out many a good book from those libraries on his way to growing up. Thank God for the extremely liberal notion that good books be available to all, not just those who would get them with a credit card at Barnes and Noble.
And you know what? He didn’t have to pay a cent to go to Will Rogers Elementary where some of yours now go, then Lincoln Middle, then Agoura High School, where he learned and read many more books — because everybody willingly chips into a common pool for the betterment of all. Now that’s the essence of liberal isn’t it, free education for all? And anything close to liberal was bashed last night by the “compassionate conservative,” wasn’t it?
Big government is a big pain, to hear it from George W. Bush. Funny how a guy can rail on and on about it while he sits at its helm. But let him tell the millions in Florida what a pain it is as they hold their hands out, seeking relief from back-to-back-to-back devastating visits from Mother Nature. The anti-liberal president, ironically, is right there, handing out big government assistance in a bleeding-heart beat. Are his true colors shining through? Or is he displaying political cunning in a state that may well deliver the decisive electoral votes once again, as he begrudgingly brings thousands of hurricane victims onto the federal dole? How many of you right here in this community cashed a FEMA check in the wake of an equally devastating visit from Mother Nature — the earthquake of January, 1994? Even the staunchest anti-big government among you welcomed the “hand-out",” I imagine. These are some mighty liberal concepts at work here, friends. Should America really be indulging in such beneficence?
You know what else is liberal? My mother and father, 77 and 79 respectively, worked hard all their lives, never to get rich. They receive a check in the mail every two weeks from big government that helps them live and love on. It’s called Social Security and there was never a more liberal concept to hit America. And if they get sick, after contributing a lifetime of honest labor to the workforce of the wealthiest nation in the history of the world, they do have at least a slightly soft place to fall, and it’s called Medicare, and it’s as liberal as the day is long.
Now George W. Bush probably told you last night about his better idea for Social Security and Medicare. Something about how he wants us to take all that money and drop it into personal stock market ventures and medical savings accounts, because he doesn’t think big government should run it. Funny, but the way he’s squandered a record national surplus into record national debt would be his best argument for getting government out of the way of our money. I wonder if he used that argument last night. He says we’d be better off with the young Gordon Geccos at Merrill Lynch handing our S.S. money off to proven winners like buddies Kenny Lay at Enron and Denny Koszlowski at Tyco, who could get you way bigger bang for your buck than any big government ever could. Only trouble is, you’ll have to wait for those guys to get out of prison before they can start gambling with your money.
He’s even coined an uplifting catch phrase that he hopes might fall off the tongue like Roosevelt’s “New Deal.” It’s his “Ownership Society.” The Bush vision is to transform America into the “Ownership Society.” Go ahead, say it out loud. Inspirational, isn’t it?
It’s bleeding-heart liberals, too, who Bush would say have corrupted the American workplace, by instituting anti-business measures like minimum wage, guaranteed overtime pay, workplace safety, child labor laws, and anti-discriminatory hiring practices. And if you lose your job — but that never happens in Bush’s America — the spend-happy liberals came up with something called “unemployment insurance,” to help you keep the lights on while you navigate your way into the next corrupted workplace.
Liberals have come up with a bevy of other harebrained concepts too, which somehow have managed to hold their ground through the current neo-conservative onslaught. Concepts like civil rights, women’s rights, gay rights, poor man’s rights, are holding on, but watch your back all of you. America has lately been officially declared “an even playing field,” and be damned if you can’t step up in here and play ball the way they say you play it. (Ron Scott Smith doesn’t want to play in the Bush game.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 14, 2004. Read the original PDF.