Skip to content

Straw man mailer mas no backbone

Published:

By Tom Larmore

(Editor’s note: The city council passed an ordinance last July requiring businesses in the coastal zone that generate more than $5 million in annual revenue to pay their employees up to $12.25 an hour. Measure JJ asks voters to approve the measure on Nov. 5. The Daily Press welcomes opinion submissions on both sides of the issue.) Over the weekend, registered Santa Monica Democrats received a letter signed by Congressman Henry Waxman and State Senator Sheila Kuehl supporting Measure JJ – the City’s Minimum Wage Ordinance.

It’s just this kind of false and misleading campaign propaganda that creates a desire for campaign finance reform. Let’s look at the points raised in this letter one at a time.

First statement: Measure JJ “raises the minimum wage for 2,000 workers concentrated in Santa Monica’s luxury beach hotels to $10.50 per hour.”

False. Measure JJ raises the minimum wage to $12.25 per hour for employees of (1) the city, (2) all companies providing services to the city (including all nonprofit organizations receiving city grants), and (3) all employers, whether profit or non-profit, having $5,000,000 in gross receipts and located in a portion of the city approximately one mile inland.

It’s not limited to “luxury beach hotels.” In fact, it will not apply to any employees of two of these hotels because they are unionized — they can, and do, pay workers less than $10.50 per hour. Almost all of the other “luxury beach hotel” employees who will be covered are already earning substantial incomes from tips.

Second statement: Measure JJ “applies only to large businesses earning more than $5 million per year.”

False. As stated above, Measure JJ applies to the city, all service contractors, both for-profit and non-profit, as well as to employers having $5 million in gross receipts. And that means “gross receipts,” not profits. Use of the term “earning” is obviously an intentional deception since that word equates with income or profits. Measure JJ applies to all employers having that level of sales irrespective of profits.

Third statement: Measure JJ “provides a hardship exemption when businesses face economic difficulties.”

False. Measure JJ says that the hardship exemption is available only when an employer can establish that compliance with Measure JJ will constitute a “severe economic hardship” rendering the business “nonviable.” The employer also must establish that any exemption will “advance the policies” of Measure JJ.

Fourth statement: “Measure JJ does not cut local public services.”

False. No one argues that it does and so to characterize the opposition argument this way is simply to knock down a straw man.

The fact is that Measure JJ will cost the city several million dollars which may lead to reduced public services, particularly during this time of economic difficulty.

Even without the $2.5-$3.0 million cost estimated by the City Manager for the first year alone, the city’s budget is in trouble. Just last week, the city disclosed that it’s already reduced revenue projections by at least another $1.5 million.

Fifth statement: Measure JJ does not “raise taxes.”

False. This statement is particularly disingenuous because no one has ever suggested Measure JJ provides for tax increases. In fact, it was a city representative who last week suggested residents might have to consider tax increases given projected shortfalls in sales taxes.

Sixth statement: Measure JJ does not “discriminate against workers.”

False. Of course it discriminates. How can one claim otherwise when JJ applies only to workers fortunate enough to work for certain businesses but not for many of their competitors? Isn’t it discrimination when employees of The Gap on the Promenade will be covered by the law but not if they’re working at the store on Wilshire? Or if they work for the Doubletree rather than the unionized Viceroy? Or for Broadway Deli but not its competitive neighbor literally across the Promenade, the Broadway Bar & Grill?

As I’ve said many times, the problems of low-wage workers is a real one that deserves serious attention. However, it will not be addressed through a law which is designed to primarily benefit the Hotel Employees and Restaurant Employees Union, Local 814 to the detriment of residents, businesses and, yes, workers, no matter how many union-supported politicians say otherwise. (Tom Larmore is a Santa Monica resident and a local property rights attorney.)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 22, 2002. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe