Skip to content

Strike up another one for home team

Strike up another one for home team
Published:

Little Leaguers’ playoff victory had mass appeal

By JOHN F. MULLER Special to the Daily Press

It’s not whether you win or lose, but how you play the game, or so the adage goes.

But for one Santa Monica Little League team, winning did matter.

After a series of controversial decisions by Little League officials, the Santa Monica East All-Stars were forced on Tuesday to replay a game they already won against the Culver City National All-Stars last week. The game was a crucial one — it meant either being eliminated from a series of tournaments leading to the Little League World Series or continue moving toward the title.

After winning last Thursday’s game, 6-3, the 11- and 12-year-old All-Stars were stripped of their victory and forced to forfeit. Following the game, officials ruled one of the Santa Monica All-Stars was ineligible to play because he had been ejected from a previous game. Little League rules prohibit ejected players from playing in their team’s subsequent game. The rules also state that coaches must play each of their players in every game.

While 12-year-old Alonzo Gonzalez was told to leave a June 26 game and “cool off” on the bench, he was not actually ejected from the game, according to Steve Heineman, the coach of the All-Stars. He said the umpire told Gonzalez to take a seat when the youngster yelled at his first base coach after a close call at first. Heineman said he didn’t approve of his player’s unsportsmanlike conduct.

“The bottom line is that 13 kids won the game with a victory on the field,” Heineman said. “And it was going to be snatched away from them because of an error and collective indifference by people that don’t have to look these kids in the face and try to explain to them what happened.”

Culver City National Little League lodged a complaint with district and national league offices after its defeat, which initially gave Culver City the victory.

After a pair of appeals, the Santa Monica All-Star coaches, parents and players were granted a rematch. Little League officials reversed their decision on the grounds that the teams had not been properly notified of Gonzalez’s eligibility. They ruled that Gonzalez had indeed been ejected from the game because the umpire had used the word “ejection.” Because Gonzalez was initially ruled eligible, officials reasoned that a rematch was the best solution.

Gonzalez was not allowed to play in Tuesday’s game, in which the Santa Monica East All-Stars prevailed again, 3-1. The team will face North Venice next. It needs another four victories to take the district title.

Heineman gave credit for the appeal’s success to the team’s parents.

“We weren’t really getting much of a response,” Heineman said. “The fact that (the parents) mobilized and made the effort to explain it from their perspective and their child’s perspective, it really forced (National Little League officials) to review their decision...

“We weren’t really getting much of a response,”
“The fact that (the parents) mobilized and made the effort to explain it from their perspective and their child’s perspective, it really forced (National Little League officials) to review their decision... “One of the most disturbing things to me was that a couple of the kids (on our team) said that a couple of their friends had told them that we were thrown out of the tournament because we cheated,”

“One of the most disturbing things to me was that a couple of the kids (on our team) said that a couple of their friends had told them that we were thrown out of the tournament because we cheated,” he added. “That, to me, was when I said ‘no, this cannot happen.’ If this wasn’t set straight by the district, that was going to be the perception.”

“That, to me, was when I said ‘no, this cannot happen.’ If this wasn’t set straight by the district, that was going to be the perception.” — Heineman said. he added
(Photo: John F. Muller/Special)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 7, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe