Skip to content

Study of oranges irrelevant to apples in living wage law

Published:

By Guest Commentary By Tom Larmore

(Editor’s note: This is one of a series of weekly columns editorializing on the hotly contested living wage ordinance. The city council passed an ordinance last July requiring businesses in the coastal zone that generate more than $5 million in annual revenue to pay their employees $12.25 an hour. Those businesses and their supporters have asked for the ordinance to be rescinded, which is before voters this November.) In their effort to have the voters approve the city’s minimum wage ordinance, supporters of that ordinance state in their ballot argument that a recent study concluded that living wage laws help reduce poverty. They can be expected to make this claim during the campaign. The truth, however, is that the report they are referring to is no more relevant to their position than their erroneous claim that the ordinance is needed to increase wages paid by luxury beach hotels.

Earlier this year, the California Public Policy Institute released a report prepared by Professor David Neumark of Michigan State University entitled “How Living Wage Laws Affect Low-Wage Workers and Low-Income Families.” Dr. Neumark is a recognized expert in the field of labor economics with a lengthy list of publications dealing with the impact of minimum wage laws on low-income workers, all of which generally conclude that the unemployment effects of such laws more than overcome any wage benefits they provide.

Dr. Neumark studied, in an admittedly preliminary manner, the effects of typical “living wage” laws on urban poverty and concluded that the evidence indicates that some of these laws appear to have a moderately positive effect. However, applying this conclusion to Santa Monica’s ordinance is terribly misleading because the laws studied by Dr. Neumark differ from the ordinance in at least in three crucial respects.

First, Dr. Neumark concluded that the benefits he perceived were achieved only in those cities having laws which covered companies receiving direct financial assistance from the city, such as tax abatements and loans. The Santa Monica law has no such component. Dr. Neumark noted that where living wage laws were limited to companies entering into service contracts with the city, there appeared to be no benefit for low-wage workers.

Second, and of crucial importance, Dr. Neumark’s study does not attempt to address a law which, like the ordinance, covers private companies having no business relationship with the city. It is this element of the ordinance which, I believe, will result in a significant negative effect for low-wage workers for reasons I have explained in previous columns.

Third, Dr. Neumark points out that inclusion of municipal employees in living wage laws is quite rare. By doing so, the Santa Monica ordinance will divert millions of taxpayer dollars away from important services in a manner which is quite unusual compared to other cities.

Therefore, when you hear or read contentions by ordinance supporters that Dr. Neumark’s study supports their position, please recognize the argument as a red herring. This study does not purport to be an analysis of a law similar to the ordinance which is, at the same time, narrower and broader in scope than the laws analyzed by Dr. Neumark. Dr. Neumark’s work concluding that typical broad form minimum wage laws reduce job opportunities for entry-level workers appears at least equally informative.

Dr. Neumark will be appearing at a luncheon program sponsored by the Chamber of Commerce on Tuesday, Aug. 27 at the Four Points Sheraton Hotel to discuss his study in the context of Santa Monica’s ordinance. He will be joined by Dr. Richard Sander of UCLA, another expert in the field of labor economics, who has conducted intensive studies of the Los Angeles living wage law. Both Dr. Neumark and Dr. Sander are quite familiar with Santa Monica’s law and are qualified to express their views on its likely effects. The cost of the luncheon is $25 and reservations can be made with Shari Wheat of the chamber at (310) 393-9825. (Tom Larmore is a Santa Monica resident and a property rights attorney.)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 20, 2002. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe