Skip to content

Sunny Kreis Santa Monica There’s a good reason for picket lines

Published:

By Marc Sanschagrin Santa Monica

Is it truly possible that anyone could be simultaneously so uninformed and yet opinionated (“Real men don’t picket” SMDP, Dec. 2, page 4). Rather than advising others to “grow up” because they don’t see an issue in the same light as herself, perhaps the woman who ranted against the striking grocery workers should consider taking a look at the issue from another point of view.

Benjamin Franklin stated over two centuries ago that “Nothing is less common than common sense.” Case in point. Does anyone truly believe grocery clerks would forgo paychecks for two months and walk picket lines for an issue that boils down to $5 a week? That’s about 12 cents an hour. Moreover, do you think union leadership could mobilize their members to walk out and keep walking over 12 cents an hour? It would take years or decades for them to make up the difference in lost wages. No, the $5 a week scam has been floated by corporate management types hoping the average person wouldn’t think the issue through and just react emotionally like, well, she did.

Negotiating a contract is a serious and complicated business that union leaders take with the utmost seriousness. Rather than crying hysteria, she might consider the truth. Workers negotiate wages and benefits in exchange for their labor. Benefits are not something management has thrown in out of the kindness of their hearts over the years. They have been earned over the years by the hard work of millions of UFCW workers. Besides, health benefits are cheaper when thousands of people work together for a group rate. If each were to try to acquire the same benefits individually, the cost would be astronomical. Most of the benefits go not to the workers themselves, but to their children. Or should the children also be out on the street earning their keep?

That’s how it was before unions. Children had the right to work 14-hour days for a dollar. Women had the right to work in sweatshops without proper lighting or ventilation. Men had the right to work until they dropped and were replaced by someone younger and stronger. Social Darwinism at its finest. Ah... the good old days. Robber barons and monopolies. Unbridled capitalism. And a life expectancy of under 50 years. But no one accused them of being wimps.

The truth is negotiators must balance their demands. Some of the remuneration comes in the form of wages. Some in pension plans. And some in benefits.

They’re not a constitutional right but a hard-won right from past negotiations. Now management wants to change all that. And not because they can’t afford it. Profits are up. They just don’t want to, and they’ve said as much. For instance, they want to cap the workers’ insurance payments on chemotherapy at $20,000. If you know any cancer survivors, that’s just about enough to extend your life long enough to allow you to wrap up your will and say good-bye to your children.

And in the interest of honesty, you and all readers should know I was a UFCW member for a decade while in high school and college — and a strike captain for Local 770 to boot. I am now the vice president of the Santa Monica-Malibu Classroom Teachers’ Association, and chair of its negotiations team. So I actually know a little bit about these issues.

Far from being bullies, our friends and neighbors walking the picket lines today are in the vanguard for all workers as management everywhere looks to cut costs and boost profits. I mean really, what are medical and dental benefits for children compared to corporate profits?

Growing up is not synonymous with growing wise. You have to work at the latter — with or without benefit.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on December 4, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe