Skip to content

Talk is cheap: Father’s affection clear all along

Published:

HIP TO BE SQUARE

By CAROLINE BODKIN

When I hung up the phone last week, I felt a short pang of guilt again for not being closer to my father, for not being more forthcoming about news in my life or easing the awkwardness of our phone calls. Ever since I was old enough to realize we could be closer, it’s something I’ve wanted.

I thought of Alyssa Milano and Tony Danza’s characters in that ’80s sitcom “Who’s the Boss?” They talked about everything — a la ’tween girls at a sleep-over, pinkie-swear fashion.

Compared to that, my dad and I had to be worlds apart.

I never considered my relationship with my dad when I was young. That’s not something you do as a child — your relationship with your parents just exists and you only think to analyze about it later, in therapy or a sociology class, or in the course of becoming an adult.

When I was just a daughter, he was just my dad, and all the things that I eventually analyzed or missed, revered or respected about our relationship’s good and bad qualities just were. But as I got older, I wondered — were we close?

When I was very young, he would hold my hand on the walk from the car, across the parking lot, to the front door of the grocery store. It made me feel safe, and yes, it demonstrated the certain kind of closeness, wherein a father is protective of his daughter.

Later, he helped me with my homework. Whenever I asked, and with endless patience, he would sit on the living room floor and concentrate with me on algebra, French or chemistry, helping me make sense of the world.

After that, he proactively blessed my flight from the nest by helping me apply to college. He drove every mile of my 10-campus tour and asked all the right questions at the admissions informational sessions, taking copious notes on financial aid and arts programs, which we’d later use to compare the schools.

And after graduating, when I announced my next move, he never questioned what I wanted to do with my life. I chose a city for no really good reason, without a job or a place to live and he was only supportive. I could have pursued modern dance in New York. He would have been at my first performance even if it were a no-costumes, attended-only-by-friends event held on someone’s rooftop in Park Slope, late July.

Protection, aid, support, kindness and the very act of being present are all signs of closeness. Yes.

But why didn’t we talk more, share more?

Why, when he or I called, did we spend five minutes updating each other on the weather before he passed me to my mom or I remembered I was on my way out?

My boyfriend was out of town last weekend at the Toronto Film Festival.

He left on a red-eye Thursday night, before I got home from work, and was scheduled to return Monday evening.

We spoke on the phone twice while he was gone and both conversations were loving, but somewhat awkward — weather updates and whatnot. We’re not good at long-distance conversations, even after two years of being together.

We talk awkwardly and then it’s clear we’re both ready to get off unless there’s something big to discuss. As a girl who grew up, like most do, with a phone glued to her ear from ages 12-17, I still get frustrated by this inability of ours to give hugs through phone wires.

But the morning after that call I got an e-mail from my boyfriend saying he missed me and was coming home a day early. When he arrived we kissed and hugged and he said he was glad to see me.

Nothing he could have said on the phone the night before would have expressed more clearly his feelings for me, or how much he missed me, more than coming home early to see me did.

That night, last night, I got a message from my dad. Just checking in before he flew home, give him a call when I have a minute, though he’s sure I’m busy like usual, he said.

I thought again for a minute how he was always there holding my hand, helping me with homework, driving me to school.

And maybe we never did have a real heart to heart on the phone, but how could that matter, I thought, remembering all those conversations we’d had that weren’t about the words? (Caroline Bodkin lives and works in Los Angeles. You can ).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 27, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe