By Ed Silverstein
The price of gas remains well over $2 a gallon despite slumping wholesale oil costs. But this is nothing new.
Oil companies have a long tradition of jacking up prices at the first whiff of bad news, but returning them to earth slower than a tree sitter. But if you think oil companies are the worst of the war profiteers, you’re wrong.
With 2001 losses from terrorism at about $10 billion after Sept. 11, insurance companies decided they no longer wanted to offer terrorism protection. After a furious lobbying effort aimed at the business-huggers who now control the White House and Congress, the insurers were rewarded with a gift. It is called the Terrorism Risk Insurance Act of 2002.
Don Griffin from the National Association of Independent Insurers, an industry trade group, said that TRIA is a temporary, three year program to protect the industry from catastrophic losses because of terrorism. According to Griffin, in the event of a terrorist attack, insurers would be responsible for only a portion of their company’s total earned premiums on business policies.
Specifically, 7 percent in the first year, 10 percent in the second year and 15 percent in the third and what is currently the last year of the program. After that threshold is reached, the government picks up 90 percent of the remaining loss.
For example, if an insurance company wrote $100 million in business insurance and had a $100 million terrorism loss during the first year of TRIA, the insurer would be responsible for the first $7 million, then 10 percent of the remaining $93 million, or a total of $16.3 million. The government would pick up the remaining $83.7 million in losses.
On the surface this seems like a good idea. After all, this administration has engaged in policies that have left potential terrorists seeing red and the rest of us seeing orange. But there’s a catch. Even though the majority of these losses are guaranteed with our taxes, the government failed to install any rate limitations.
This has left the door open for insurers to price gouge. The industry claims that there are safeguards, referring to a CRS assessment that policyholders who perceive the prices as unfair will likely appeal to their state insurance departments, which retain authority under TRIA to invalidate excessive or discriminatory rates.
The problem with this is twofold. Many state representatives, as well as insurance commissioners (remember Chuck Quakenbush?) are beholden to big money insurance interests. As a result, there is little inclination to regulate this type of product.
But even more worrisome is that, during this current Insurance crisis, carriers are fleeing the state faster than rats off a sinking ship. For an ever-increasing number of Californians, particularly if, like my condo association, the property has had even a single loss, the only product available is from non-admitted carriers.
One broker I spoke with claimed that over 50 percent of new policies he’s writing are with these non-admitted carriers. Not only are these policies far more expensive, but the State Insurance Commission has little or no jurisdiction over these insurers. That means they can charge whatever they like for terrorism insurance. And they do.
I recently received quotes for terrorism insurance on two properties.
A 47-unit apartment building, which is insured by an admitted carrier for nearly $4 million, had a terrorism premium of $310. A five-unit condo building, that is insured by a non-admitted carrier for only $800,000, had a premium of $500. This is 65 percent more than the apartment building, but offering only one-fifth the coverage.
Price gouging aside, there is an even bigger issue. Is this type of insurance worth it?
The likelihood of a building or a business, with the exception of 100-story skyscrapers, theme parks or a few other high profile businesses, being the target of a terrorist attack is minuscule. A Defense Department source working with terrorism, who declined to be named, told me that you are more likely to be attacked by a shark than to be a victim of terrorism.
And then there’s the issue of what these policies actually cover.
A plane falling out of the sky or a conventional bombing would be covered. But nuclear attacks are out. So are, in almost all cases, chemical or biological attacks. With these risks eliminated, the likely probability of being a victim of a covered terrorist incident is about the same as George W. Bush being invited to be the keynote speaker at a NARAL fund raising dinner hosted by Bob Jones University.
So why are these insurance companies charging so much?
The likely answer is fear. Insurance companies, the ethical equivalent of a tobacco company executive, are not beneath exploiting the Sept. 11 tragedy and the war with Iraq. And this possible new law allows insurers to line their pockets with profits while the taxpayers are saddled with the lion’s share of liability.
And what do our representatives think about all this?
Calls to U.S. Sen. Barbara Boxer and U.S. Sen. Diane Feinstein’s office were not returned. Congressman Henry Waxman’s office sent an analysis of the bill, but had no further comment.
One thing is for sure. Any time government and big business get together, it’s like watching a street performer at a pickpocket convention. I, for one, will keep a tight grip on my wallet. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer living in Santa Monica. To insure that I read your comments e-mail them to:)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 9, 2003. Read the original PDF.