By William M. Price Santa Monica
Regarding Dr. Ghate’s guest commentary, (SMDP, Feb. 3, page 4). In his criticism of eco-terrorists, he writes only about the glorious accomplishments of the industrial complex, and there are a lot more of these than he actually mentions. However, there are also many, many things that we are doing wrong to accomplish these ends. I too deplore the activities of the Earth Liberation Front and the various animal rights groups. Not only are their actions criminal, but they give a bad name to the legitimate concerns voiced by rational individuals. There is a tendency by many to lump such concerns as just the ranting of more radicals. Dr. Ghate’s article does not separate the voices of reason from those of the radicals. His article seems to imply that: (1) anyone who voices concern over what we are doing to the environment is an eco-terrorist or at least a potential one. (2) Environmentalists care more for plants and animals than we do for fellow humans. (3) Environmentalists “long for the good old days.” Nothing could be further from the truth. It is precisely because we care for the quality of life and the welfare of our fellow humans, now and for the future, that we speak up. It is obvious that he has either never studied the science of human ecology, or if he has, he has forgotten it, or perhaps he is deliberately ignoring the facts and warnings as so many with vested interests do.
Human ecology, which studies the effects humans have had on the environment, tells us that the problems of global warming, air pollution, water pollution, mineral resource depletion (including oil), depletion of soil, declining amounts of food per capita, the population explosion and the decrease in diversity of ecosystems do not portent well for our future. Many people are aware that as the demand for the declining oil reserves increases, the price of gasoline increases. But, most do not realize that the cost of food is proportional to the cost of oil. We need alternative energy sources. Also, most do not realize that our welfare depends upon the vast diversity of life forms on this planet. So when we eliminate plants and animals, as we alter ecosystems to fit our present needs, we decrease future generations’ ability to survive. Yes, the quality of life in industrialized nations is vastly better than it was a few hundred years ago. But what will be the quality of life for our grandchildren and great grandchildren when they have to deal with the polluted air, lakes, streams and oceans that have resulted from our present manufacturing plants and agricultural practices? When we have torn down most of the forests of the world for wood, fuel and new developments? (See Jared Diamond’s best selling book: “Collapse”). Environmentalists are not against increasing the quality of life, but against the present ways we try to accomplish those goals. As presently practiced, the human systems of waste management, resource retrieval, food production, energy production, transportation, etc. are unsustainable. That is, we cannot continue to do in the future as we have been doing in the past. For one thing, the resources of the planet are finite and at the present rate of consumption, we will run out of them in the very near future. For another, we are producing toxic wastes faster than the planet can render them safe. For instance, we have yet to come up with a safe method Scientists do not consider radioactive material to be safe until seven to eight half-lives have passed. Perhaps the reason some have resorted to eco-terrorism is their frustration with the failure of industry and governments to recognize that there are problems and to instigate reforms in the way we do business. Frustrated because most say it will cost too much to change. Frustration in the ways we have used and continue to use to support our life style. So, yes we do have a much better life style today than yesterday. But there are questions to be answered: What is the cost up to now and in the future? Can we continue to do things as we have in the past? Can the other half of the world, the developing nations, achieve “success” in the same way we have? If the answer to the latter two is “no.”
Then what must we do differently to ensure a continued high quality of life for ourselves and our children’s children? That is what environmentalists are trying to draw attention to from the populace, industry and government. We are trying to point out these problems and get institutions to work on them. Some of these need immediate attention. Solving them will not be easy. It will take a meeting of the minds between sociologists, economists and politicians, as well as input from a knowledgeable and enlightened public. Remember, because we voice concern, we are not eco-terrorists or radicals, but concerned citizens.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 8, 2006. Read the original PDF.