By INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN
A general launches a nuclear attack against Russia, ranting that a communist plot — water fluoridation — has left him impotent. It is here, in Stanley Kubric’s film, “Dr. Strangelove,” that I first hear about fluoridation and I am left with the distinct impression that all water fluoridation opponents are crazy. To be honest, many of the current opponents do little to dispel that notion. However, that doesn’t mean that they’re wrong.
Like most people, I was convinced that water fluoridation was completely safe. That is, until I read “The Fluoride Deception” by Christopher Bryson, an award-winning and very sane investigative journalist. Bryson, who supports his allegations with extensive research, paints a disturbing and frightening picture of the effects of fluoride in the water, air and work place.
Bryson explains that the main element of fluoride — fluorine — can cut through steel like butter, burn asbestos, etch glass and disintegrate organic material as if it were a fizzy. And for the past 50 years the Public Health Service, National Institute of Health, Institute For Dental Health and the American Dental Association have insisted that fluoride, in extremely diluted concentrations, is perfectly safe to drink and will reduce cavities. For 50 years they have been wrong.
For starters, Bryson notes that the fluoride used in tests was pharmaceutical grade without impurities. In contrast, the fluoride used in our water is scrubbed from the smokestacks of phosphate fertilizer plants and has high levels of cancer causing arsenic and lead. This alone is reason for concern, but it gets worse.
The pure fluoride was used in Newburgh, NY., the first city to receive fluoridation. The town was studied for 10 years and the results proclaimed that Newburgh's children had 65 percent fewer cavities and no negative health effects. In fact, this was not entirely true.
Neighboring Kingston, the control city in the study and which has never had fluoride, today has the exact same rate of cavities as fluoridated Newburgh. Even proponents now admit that fluoride is only responsible for a 15 percent decrease in cavities. Further, according to the Center for Disease Control, this small reduction is achieved through topical fluoride applications, with no benefit derived from ingested fluoride. But the announcement of a new genetic test developed by USC can tell with 97 percent accuracy that the exact number of cavities a child will get shows no significant impact of fluoride at all.
Research also has begun to demonstrate that fluoride is anything but benign. For instance, about 45 percent of kids drinking fluoridated water develop dental fluorosis, a mottling of the teeth. Originally dismissed as cosmetic, new information suggests that fluorosis may indicate a weakening of the tooth structure. Researchers also have noted a 50 percent increase in hip and other bone fractures, as well as higher rates of bone and liver cancer in cities with fluoridation. One statistic mysteriously omitted from the original Newburgh study was that after five years of fluoridation, the city experienced a 50 percent increase in heart disease.
More recent studies have linked fluoride with thyroid problems, Downs Syndrome, arthritis, central nervous system disorders, breathing difficulties, premature puberty in girls and other disorders. It has also been shown that fluoride can carry aluminum into the brain, which can cause Alzheimer’s lesions.
So why have we not heard more about these studies? Because scientists are frightened of having their careers and reputations destroyed.
But why would such a dangerous drug be added to our water, as it recently was here in Santa Monica?
Bryson explains that during WWII, and in the build-up to the Cold War, workers were exposed to high levels of fluoride in places such as aluminum processing plants, chemical companies, automotive factories and the atomic weapons programs. These workers had developed dozens of debilitating and even fatal diseases. Further, releases of fluoride into the air had destroyed crops, killed cattle and sickened ranchers and their families. Thousands of lawsuits were a virtual certainty.
The industries needed cover. They banded together and hired the Melon Institute to do fluoride safety studies. What they got were results that ignored, suppressed and even falsified negative findings.
One study, for example, claimed that workers at a factory had fewer cavities, but failed to mention that the workers had no teeth, probably the result of fluoride poisoning. Another, the paperwork of which was discovered by Bryson in an abandoned lab, was halted and concealed when industry scientists realized that it would prove that fluoride inhalation caused the very lung damage claimed by workers. And those skewed results were later used by government agencies — many run by ex-industry scientists — to assure the public that fluoride was perfectly safe.
But the coup de gråce was when industries got behind the then faltering effort to promote water fluoridation. To insure success, they enlisted an esteemed scientist, Dr. Harold Hodge, to act as the chief proponent for water fluoridation. Years later, Hodge would be exposed as the architect of human radiation experiments in which plutonium was injected into unsuspecting patients — many of them retarded children. The industries reasoned that if the government determined that fluoride was safe enough for our drinking water, then it would be virtually impossible for a defendant to win a lawsuit. And that is exactly what happened.
One thing is for certain. Any benefit fluoride might provide is vastly outweighed by its potential health danger. And with Santa Monica joining the ranks of cities with fluoridated water, Bryson’s book should be required reading for every member of the City Council.
But don’t believe me, just read your toothpaste’s warning label. (Ed Silverstein)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on March 9, 2005. Read the original PDF.