By Maria Bell Santa Monica
With respect to Georja Umano’s letter (SMDP, June 28, page 7) about the dog beach, and her opinion and “survey” claiming that all dog beaches in California are welcomed, this is simply not the case. On its face, a “dog beach” is a great idea. It allows dogs to run in an atmosphere that, for a dog, is compelling. However, environmental and other factors must be considered.
Most beaches cited as examples of dog beaches that work use anecdotal information from the people that use them, not those that live around them or that do not use them.
I have explored almost every inch of the California coastline and have witnessed dog beaches that work. Most that I have seen do not. Most that work are in isolated areas where few people recreate or live, or, the beach really isn’t a beach. Take Fiesta Island in San Diego — while listed as a dog beach, Fiesta Island (the name gives it away) is a man-made atoll that is uninhabited less for the jet skiers, partiers and the infamous “Over the Line Tournament.” However, even there, joggers, bird watchers and rowers often complain to animal control when they step on a recent nugget or get bit. Ocean Beach in San Diego isn’t much better as it is dirty and neighbors frequently complain.
Another problem that is occurring in Northern California, particularly in places like B-Beach and in Santa Cruz, is unabashed defecation and unruly behavior from animals that are not fenced in and thus come into contact with different elements, including aggressive animals that have attacked smaller ones.
Clearly, Ms. Umano is passionate about her dogs. This was evident at the most recent “Dog Party” where many of the dog owners, (and I am told included Georja) dressed their animals up like humans. I would venture to guess that Georja is much like the gentleman down at the coffee shop that when asked to leash his dog, retorted, “He isn’t a dog, he is my son.”
My point is that even though dog owners (and I was one for most of my life) have incredible facilities here in Santa Monica with respect to off-leash dog parks, they always want more. The question becomes, “to what degree do we humans that may or may not own pets give up and jeopardize our space to accommodate free and unrestricted animals?” And, to what degree do we jeopardize our health, safety and peace of mind to accommodate our pets? Just ask the residents around the Joslyn Park dog run that question.
With the increasing amount of human activities taking place outdoors, Santa Monica beaches, less for a few months in the winter, are far too crowded, and the health and safety hazards are far too great for a dog beach.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on June 29, 2004. Read the original PDF.