By Evelyn Jerome
■ For the past week, the parking lots and aisles of local grocery stores have been nearly empty as striking workers have attempted to make their case in the court of public opinion. It’s contract negotiation time, and workers at Vons, Ralph’s, and Albertson’s markets have drawn a line in the sand as the supermarket chains review the salaries and benefits packages they will offer their employees.
Salaries aren’t even much of an issue this time — with skyrocketing health insurance costs, employers now seek to cut the amount that they will contribute to health care benefit plans.
And here’s an interesting concept: You’ll notice that I used the word “negotiation.” Negotiation, according to the venerable Webster’s, means “to settle by bargaining.” Bargaining brings to mind a “give and take” from both sides. But before a settlement could be reached, in fact with just a preliminary offer on the table which slightly cut some health care benefits, the union representing the grocery store employees walked out. They handed their guys some picket signs and walked out.
In case you haven’t noticed, the economy hasn’t been so great lately. Nobody’s business is really booming these days, and everyone, from single moms to Fortune 100 companies, is finding ways to make ends meet. One way business owners cut costs is to keep salaries level but reduce benefits. The other way to cut costs, here at contract time when everything is up for grabs, is to reduce the number of employees overall, or reduce each employee’s hours. Would the strikers prefer this solution?
I think striking is the adult version of collecting one’s toys from the sandbox and going home. I’m not against the right to unionize — in fact, I completely support the concept of unions protecting workers from unreasonable employers and unsafe working conditions. But I’m against childish behavior that doesn’t accomplish anything — and it’s difficult to argue that $20 an hour with any benefits for semi-skilled work is unreasonable in this soft job market.
I’m opposed to the strikers blocking driveways and accosting customers as they attempt to shop because not only is it juvenile but it isn’t very smart to scare away your employers’ customers, now is it? Who knows if they’ll ever come back.
Finally, I’m amused that guilty Westsiders are skipping their usual trip to Ralph’s and “supporting” striking workers by shopping Trader Joe’s, whose nonunion but cheerful employees are paid less than the strikers. Moral support is nice but it doesn’t pay the rent. (Evelyn Jerome is the founder and principal of Strategic Communications, a communications consulting firm. She is a past president of the Los Angeles County Young Democrats and a Santa Monica homeowner. To respond or to reach her, e-mail).
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 21, 2003. Read the original PDF.