By HERE’S THE THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D
Nearly two weeks ago, the Gulf region was pounded by Hurricane Katrina, and the horrific images of people suffering and dying have yet to cease. No doubt many share the sentiment expressed by one of our founding fathers, Alexander Hamilton, who after surviving a hurricane on St. Croix, wrote: “My heart bleeds, and I have no power to solace.”
Our hearts do bleed for our fellow Americans. And the awfulness comes not from the bleeding, but from the lack of power. Most of us have been unable to do anything, except to donate to the Red Cross, Habitat for Humanity and/or PETA. Most of us have felt like yelling: “Please, somebody, do something! Please help all of those people stranded, hurt and in harm’s way!”
What’s made this situation so untenable was that most of the elected officials in the federal government — President George Bush included — were on vacation when this happened. Bush was still on his ranch in Texas, and neither Louisiana Senators David Vitter, nor Mary Landrieu, had the power to rouse their colleagues from their breaks. While Vitter is a Republican, he was elected less than a year ago, which means he has few favors saved up to ask for help. Landrieu, who has more seniority, also happens to be a Democrat, which means that her influence is severely constrained in Washington these days. In addition, since Bush believes in delegating authority, it is doubtful that he felt that he needed to micro-manage a storm, especially one that had already passed by his brother’s state.
This is not to say that the state and local officials didn’t make errors regarding Katrina. They did. But it was the disappearing act of almost all of the federal elected officials that worried me the most. And it wasn’t just that Bush was missing in action, though of course, that was the most disturbing. It was that they all were, with the glaring exceptions of Senator Bill Frist and former Vice President Al Gore. Frist hopped on a plane and volunteered his medical services, while Gore chartered a plane and flew doctors into the region and evacuees out.
The Bush administration has said contradictorily that: (a) they couldn’t get in because of the damage, (b) they weren’t invited into the state by the governor, and (c) they thought the storm had passed without severe damage, but then the levees broke, which was why they were caught unaware. Simply put, they are nothing but excuses.
On Monday, Aug. 29, beginning at about 7 a.m., Katrina made landfall. By 11 a.m., two major levees were breached and massive flooding began to occur in New Orleans. By Tuesday morning, water had encompassed more than 80 percent of the city and New Orleans was without power, water, gas and phone service.
While it is true that during the storm FEMA and the National Guard were unable to move people and supplies into the city, the federal government still could have been acting on the region’s behalf. Within the White House, there is an individual who is in charge of intergovernmental relations, and that person could have been on the phone with the National Governor’s Association and he could have been working with the 47 governors not impacted by the storm to coordinate relief efforts. Instead of waiting for each state to offer assistance (days later), the federal government could have been organizing the state assistance program.
The same is true with regard to the private sector. The White House could have been on the phone with heads of Fortune 500 companies coordinating the private sector relief. Had the federal government been engaged in these types of efforts on Monday, FEMA, the Red Cross, and the states of Louisiana, Mississippi and Alabama would not have been scrambling as hard and as fast as they were late last week.
Here’s the Thing: While I could go on about the failures of the Bush administration, I’m more concerned about the failures of the presidential aspirants. Bush is a lame duck. The presidential aspirants — Hillary Clinton, John Edwards, Evan Bayh, Rudolph Guiliani, John McCain, Rick Santorum (to name a few) — are the future and they were not there. They did not show themselves in Louisiana, Mississippi or Alabama any faster than did Bush. They are the ones who are telling me that they have the leadership skills to run this country. How am I supposed to believe that they are any better than what we have now, given that they didn’t get there to help any faster than Bush?
Leadership is not simply about words. It’s about action. And the only two who took action were two Tennesseans considered long-shots. Wonder what a Frist versus Gore race might look like? (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is a political scientist from Los Angeles, and teaches at California State University, Channel Islands. She)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 9, 2005. Read the original PDF.