Skip to content

The feudal heritage of today’s commercial lease

Published:

By IN YOUR SPACE BY CHRISTINA S. PORTER

Just what is a commercial lease? The best definition of a lease that I could find is “the separation of ownership and possession.” The tenant effectively buys the right to possess the property from the owner. Believe it or not, commercial leasing has been going on for 800 years. It seems that the practice began in feudal England where the landowners leased their land to farmers. Although it has the same name, the term “lease” we use today has changed significantly. In feudal England, a lease was considered a conveyance of the property for a specified term, at the end of which possession of the property reverted back to the owner. This reversion was the owner’s only interest in the property during the term of the lease. Other than assuring the tenant of what we today call the right to “quiet enjoyment,” meaning that the lessor will protect the tenant’s right to possess the property, the owner had no other obligations to the tenant. That is clearly not the case today. According to Mark A. Senn, Esq., an expert on commercial real estate leases, the lease today has evolved into a hybrid conveyance and contract and seems to be leaning more toward being simply a contract.

The evolution began with the industrial revolution. In feudal England the only thing being leased was land. When the industrial revolution came about not only was land being leased but commercial buildings were being leased and many times, as part of the lease agreement, the landlord would make promises to the tenants to provide electricity, among other things. For many years, if the landlord failed to perform the duties promised in a lease the tenant would still be obligated to pay the rent because of the court’s reliance on the feudal idea of conveyance rather than contract law. When the land was “conveyed” and possession transferred, the owner had no other obligations, even if he promised to provide other things. Hence, the lease’s evolution to a contract. Although there are benefits to owners having a contract as opposed to a conveyance of the property, this evolution benefits the tenant for the most part. For example, the landlord’s obligation to mitigate damages from a tenant breach. This means that the landlord cannot collect damages because of a tenant’s breach if he could have avoided the damages by attempting to release the space immediately if the tenant has moved out and refused to or cannot pay. When the lease was considered a conveyance, the landlord was not obligated to do anything and the damages would simply accumulate.

There are several other benefits to the lease being a contract instead of a conveyance. One of them is the “implied doctrine” in a contract of good faith and fair dealing, meaning you are obligated and expected to tell the truth. Another is one that is very important is in the consent area of the lease. A “landlord’s consent shall not be unreasonably withheld” would never have been part of a conveyance but is a great benefit to tenants today, particularly when they might need to sublease.

Interestingly enough, you could say that the evolution of the lease has come full circle in the form of an absolute triple net lease. In an absolute triple net lease the landlord’s entire burden of ownership is passed on to the tenant. An interesting comparison is between a mortgage and a lease. (The above information is meant for informational purposes only and not meant to be taken as advice. Christina S. Porter is in the business of leasing and selling office and industrial building and (310) 806-6104 or at).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 12, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe