By Beatrice H. Nemlaha Santa Monica
Editor: I’m not enthusiastic about continuing a paper debate with Tom Larmore, but a few observations are in order about his June 26, 2002 letter responding to my June 25, 2002 MYTHS and FACTS letter. Mr. Larmore is a real estate attorney so he knows: In this country local governments are responsible for the welfare and safety of their citizens. This includes land use planning, development, and regulation. The job of regulating land use is done through ordinances and commissions, it involves complicated issues, and it is not done quickly and easily.
When the Landmarks or other Commission reviews property use plans, it is not “taking control of the property.” Flexible remodel guidelines and variances allow owners to adapt and change their properties.
Preservation ordinances designed to protect individual buildings and neighborhoods which have architectural, historic, and cultural significance in their cities have been upheld by our courts at all levels, including the U.S. Supreme Court. Designating an individual building as a landmark or a neighborhood as an historic district is not spot zoning.
No one has yet offered anything other than speculation and conjecture that designating a uniquely special property as a landmark or a few blocks as an historic district would have a negative impact on property values. This is especially true for people who bought into Santa Monica before the current boom in real estate prices and have seen their properties increase many fold. Long-term property owners have nothing to fear, but speculators may, simply because their investment timing may be off.
In the final analysis, though, the real question for all of us who chose Santa Monica as our home is how to achieve the best balance between a conflicting public good and private desires in those instances where a special home is threatened with demolition or the character of a special neighborhood is in danger of irreversible damage. Remember, we’re not talking about the majority of homes or neighborhoods, but a rare few.
The initiative proposed by the Homeowners for Voluntary Preservation has many flaws, but for now consider just these few.
If all owners of a property must consent to designation as a landmark or inclusion in an historic district, one of several owners of a property could block that designation even if a majority desired it. Do we really want a system in which one individual can thwart the desires of the many? I don’t.
Do we really want a community in which we are helpless to stop the demolition or tasteless remodel of our truly unique, truly special one or few-of-a-kind extraordinary buildings if whoever happens to own the property at the moment wants to go that way? I don’t.
Historic districts only make sense if they have a high concentration of original structures (including those remodeled consistently with their principal architectural features). Historic districts simply are not possible if individual properties can opt out. Do we want to give a few property owners the ability to prevent or destroy an historic district beyond recognition even if many or most residents in a neighborhood want a district? I don’t.
If the initiative Mr. Larmore supports ultimately reaches the ballot and is passed, it will mean that Santa Monica will be powerless to protect the most important of its architectural resources and neighborhoods, whether those are threatened by speculators and developers (small and large, individual and corporate) or by individual homeowners in for the short as well as the long-term.
I don’t want that to happen in Santa Monica, and it’s a terrible simplification for Mr. Larmore to state that opponents of the initiative he champions have only one simple “trust them” theme. City governance and balancing public and private interests is far more complex than that, and I do believe Mr. Larmore in his heart must know that.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 2, 2002. Read the original PDF.