Skip to content

The good, bad and ugly in customer development

Published:

By & VIEWS BY DAVID PISARRA

No matter what the product or service is, marketing is the lifeblood of any organization. It is one of my great passions to observe others in their marketing efforts. Occasionally I see shining examples of exciting, engaging, fantastic marketing programs, but more often than not, I see horrible, terrible, tremendously stupid marketing.

Marketing is far more than simply putting together a brochure or flyer, and taking out a print ad in a newspaper. It is the process of developing someone’s complete experience with your organization. It includes the little things such as “thank you” notes, and big things such as automated phone systems.

I had an occasion this past week to cash a check. This simple act, which in a time long before the advent of ATMs was the normal course of business, has become rare.

In the banking world, the capture of new clients is of great value. Any new client is a source of new deposits, and that means fees for new accounts. As each bank has become more consolidated, they each fight for ways to capture and keep new clients.

Late last week, I went to U.S. Bank to cash a check from a client. Because it was made out to me and they had enough money in the account, this should not have been more than a 30-second transaction. In all likelihood, it should not have affected my opinion of this bank. However, in an effort to capture my business, U.S. Bank has instituted a “non-account holder” processing fee of $5 to cash a check.

This is legal, and I am confident that there is a battery of lawyers on the bank’s side who have researched it to make sure that they comply with the law.

When I was told that I was going to have to pay this fee, I asked for a manager. He was clearly annoyed that I should dare to invade his highly regarded duties of wandering around trying to look important. When I said that this was an appalling charge and no way to build customers, he gave me one of those it’s-not-my-fault looks and said, “Don’t shoot the messenger. It’s the law, so long as we have it posted.”

It was obvious he was sure that would make me go away.

Being who I am, I asked for a copy of the law. He was efficient in how quickly he grabbed the little blue sheet that explained to me how I could avoid the charge if only I would open an account, but he didn’t actually provide me with anything that stated a U.S. code section or a California code, so frankly it could all be just a scam by the manager and his minions at the bank.

The bank has a way that I can avoid paying the $5 fee. If I feel like opening a new account with a $100 minimum, they will waive the “non-account” holder fee.

For a brief second it occurred to me that I should make them open an account in my name, for the $100, cash the bloody check, and then close my new account. Which surely would have taken up lots of time and annoyed everyone in the process, including me.

Providing someone with a “benefit” in this manner is the type of marketing that is punishment driven. It comes from a desire by the bank to turn a one-time customer into a long-time customer. It didn’t work on me.

In fact, what it did do was make me disgusted with the bank, mad at the people who wrote me a check on U.S. Bank’s account, and angered me so much that I called my banker at First Regional Bank to determine if they charge my clients money when they cash a check. I was told that they don’t, and I got the impression my banker thought it rather petty of the manager not to waive the fee.

Punishment doesn’t seem to work well as a way to induce behavior. Particularly with Americans, we tend to rebel against it. Personally, I will never set foot in a U.S. Bank again, and I will actively discourage from U.S. Bank any clients who ask me for a good bank. My bank, First Regional, is a superb example of what a bank should be. They are efficient, and I can get a hold of someone to take care of my needs without having to go through an automated system, all the while being told that, “We care about our customers, you are important, and we value you,” as they slowly drive me insane while avoiding actually helping me.

In the interests of honesty, I should note that I do have accounts with three other banking institutions, so it is not as if I am acting in the dark here. I work with banks and bankers a fair amount. I tend to understand their motivations and what makes them tick.

What appalls me here is that U.S. Bank thinks it is achieving new customers by giving them the benefit of “free check cashing” if they become a depositor, when in fact, what they are doing is driving away customers.

I understand in the banking world that there is a need to cut costs, and the fewer teller transactions that occur, the fewer tellers they need. But charging a non-customer to cash a check is an affront to the people whose money they hold and insulting to the person who is trying to get paid.

It is this type of marketing that is bad. The type of marketing that allows me to get directly to my banker is good. Now, we need to see more of it. (David Pisarra is a business development lawyer in the Santa Monica firm of Pisarra & Grist. He welcomes your questions and comments. He or (310) 664-9969).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 24, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe