By Jodi Summers
Residents of Santa Monica are rightfully proud of our world-famous seaside community. So is our local government, which is doing its best to preserve Santa Monica’s historic charm — whether the owners of landmark homes like it or not.
“Landmarking, like anything that restricts your development of a property, affects value,” observes Melissa Macfadyen, who has been selling real estate in Santa Monica for 14 years. “Any additional government regulation over the use of a property impacts its value — whether it’s landmark status, low income housing, rent control, etc. The government rarely elects to put regulations on your use of a property that make it more valuable.”
Who gets to designate and landmark Santa Monica properties is the reason for the current special election for the Homeowners Freedom of Choice Initiative. If approved, homeowners will be able to choose whether or not their homes are designated a landmark. The Homeowners Freedom of Choice Initiative is Santa Monica’s first mail-in election, with voters receiving ballots by mail and returning them either by postal service or via City Hall. The voting period is 29 days, beginning Feb. 20 and ending March 21 at 9 p.m.
If approved, the initiative would prohibit the city from designating any home in a residential district as a “landmark” or a “structure of merit” or including a home within a “historic district” without owner consent.
The existing law states that homes more than 40 years old must have the Landmarks Commission’s approval before being demolished.
Currently, changes that can be made to a landmark home’s exterior are limited, and require city approval.
If the Freedom of Choice Initiative passes, the benefits of landmarking a property will include tax incentives, fee waivers, streamlined remodeling reviews and limited zoning exemptions. The initiative also gives the commission only 90 days to decide on a historic district and allows homeowners to cancel the proposal if 51 percent of the neighborhood express written opposition.
“They say, ‘If you have a landmark status property you get your taxes lowered.’
How does that compensate you for having a useless piece of property?” questions real estate developer Jan Feldman. “The city should stay out of private property rights.”
“Landmarking is part of zoning. Leaving it up to individual homeowners gives them unchecked control over something that affects everybody,” observed Landmarks Commissioner Nina Fresco. “… No one individual should have the right to determine something that affects the development of an entire neighborhood.”
The Landmark committee has helped preserved such noteworthy local sites as the Santa Monica Pier, the Carousel and homes by John Byers, Paul Wlliams, Frank Lloyd Wright and Frank Gehry, as well as two homes built by founding father Roy Jones. The committee declares that the only reason the Oscar Neimeyer house on La Mesa Drive still stands is because of Santa Monica’s authority to designate a landmark property without owner consent.
Santa Monica, like 20 other California cities such as Los Angeles, San Francisco, Sacramento, Oakland, Oceanside, Santa Barbara, and Long Beach does NOT have a voluntary ordinance. Nor do Ann Arbor, Boston, Chicago, Dallas, El Paso, New York, Nashville, Orlando, Philadelphia or Portland require owner consent to confer landmark status.
“If an alteration is proposed, the changes are evaluated through the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards, which are nationally accepted. This research is standard and impartial,” Fresco noted.
According to the city, there are 6,586 parcels zoned R-1 in Santa Monica. Of those, 5,302 were constructed in or prior to 1952, making them eligible to be landmarked. Currently there are 400 residential properties listed in the city’s historic resources inventory, 348 of which are north of Montana Avenue — 42 are official landmarks. Recently, the owners of the Merle Norman building on Main Street and a home on Georgina Avenue requested landmark designation.
“Many Santa Monica homeowners are just regular people that were lucky enough to buy homes when the area was affordable,” Feldman said. “The last group of people that the city should be picking on is the homeowners.” (Jodi Summers is a real estate agent at Boardwalk Realty. If you have local real estate questions or opinions you’d like to share, e-mail them to Jodi Summers at)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 21, 2003. Read the original PDF.