By CAROLINE BODKIN
When you’re somewhere away from home — visiting a friend at the college you almost went to, or on vacation in another city, another country, another town — it’s hard not to imagine what your life would be like if you lived there.
What if I went to that other school? What if I lived on Maui full time? What if I gave up my city for this one? What if I gave up city life for country living? Are there better jobs here? Is there more to do?
Could I give up my life for the one I see here?
My boyfriend and I live in a big, dirty, exciting but exhausting city. A big part of us longs to go back to a small town with open space and clean air. We stay in the city because there are things we want to do, achieve, go for and finish there that can’t be done, achieved or attempted elsewhere.
But when my boyfriend and I were on vacation in northern Maine, we found ourselves asking all those “what if” questions.
What if we moved to this small town? Could we grant ourselves the quiet life we crave, on this beautiful coast, knowing that it would mean giving up the things that we’re “going for” in the city?
The real question is, do our reasons for staying put justify ignoring the fact that we might truly be happier somewhere else? Is it worth sticking it out?
On day four of our vacation, while sitting at the bar in our favorite restaurant, we were indulging this “what if” dialogue on how we’d make a living in our new home when the owner of the restaurant slid behind the bar.
He paused to listen, then smiled and nodded.
This sort of conversation must amuse him because at age 26, he has already made his decision. He ducked out of the New York restaurant scene three years ago to do just what he wanted, just where he wanted.
We asked him how business was going, and he said it’d been a slow summer due to July’s heavy rains, but that things were picking up and should be steady until they closed on Columbus Day.
He’d spend the winter traveling and hoped things would be better next year.
I believe in this place, he said, it just takes time. Weeds grow overnight, but trees take time. He’d have to stick it out to find out, and he planned to give it his all in the meantime.
The grass is greener mentality is either a great liability or a real motivation. If you’re always thinking about the better life that you could live elsewhere, how are you supposed to give your all to the life you have?
On the other hand, is it possible that you would be happier if you made the major changes you daydream about?
When we got back from the bar, I received a message from an old friend. It said something like this: “I’ve decided that my current job’s a dead end and have given my notice. I’m not sure what’s next, but I’d be happy to hear your thoughts.”
This friend had bounced around from job to job and city to city since he graduated college.
He’d had seemingly good opportunities in all these places, so it was hard to understand why he’d never found one that stuck. It seems there’s a difference between something that sticks to you and your deciding to stick something out. While one is obvious, the other takes faith and determination.
After that, my boyfriend and I made a list. All the things we liked about our life that are specific to the city in which we live: Our friends, the opportunities and the stones yet unturned.
When we returned from vacation, I called my friend and consoled him about leaving his latest job and city. He gave me a rundown on his new plan, and he asked me if I thought this one would work.
I said he’d be OK wherever he ends up, whatever he decides to do.
Life does work out. He pressed me, asking, “But do you think it’s going to work this time?”
And I paused, considered, and said, “I guess you’ll have to give it your all if you want to find out.”
Because that’s all I’ve got to go on, too. (Caroline Bodkin lives in LA for the time being.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 13, 2004. Read the original PDF.