Skip to content

The hidden cost in your mutual funds

Published:

By ROB JUPILLE

Mutual funds are arguably one of the best ways for small investors to participate in the stock market. They provide access to professional money managers, allow smaller dollar contributions than would be required to build a diversified portfolio of individual stocks, and are typically very liquid, providing flexibility.

All of the advantages of mutual funds do come at a cost, however. One cost, in particular, can have a major impact on your fund’s performance but is invisible to many individuals and, quite frankly quite a few “professional” financial advisors. This is the cost associated with the trading done by the fund manager.

In order to generate returns, mutual fund managers buy and sell stocks during the year. Fund managers, just like individuals, pay brokerage fees when they trade. What might surprise you is that, because of the large number of shares they trade, mutual funds often pay more in trading costs than you or I would.

Here’s an example: If XYZ stock is selling for $60 and you want to buy 200 shares, you call your broker and you’ll get 200 shares of XYZ at $60 each. If a fund manager, managing a multi-billion dollar fund, wants to buy XYZ, he or she may need to purchase 1 million shares. When that order gets put into the market for that many shares, what do you think happens to the price of XZY? That’s right, because the fund is buying so many shares, the price of the stock goes up. It’s a case of basic supply-and-demand economics.

So if XYZ is selling at $60 and the manager needs 1 million shares, as the market climbs, he or she may get a few at $60, some more at $60.50, a few more at $61, etc. John Bogle, chairman of Vanguard Funds and a noted mutual fund expert, estimates that each time a fund buys or sells a stock, the average cost of this price increase is 6/10 of one percent.

So what does that mean in actual dollars, and how can you check the costs of the funds you own? Actually, it’s a pretty simple process. If you have access to a service such as Morningstar, look for your fund’s “turnover ratio.” This number tells you how many times the manager essentially bought and sold the entire portfolio over the course of the year.

Since each purchase and sale incurs.6 percent in costs, that means that for every 100 percent turnover in a fund, the cost to you, the investor, is 1.2 percent. Since the average U.S. stock fund carries approximately a 110 percent turnover ratio, you will pay 1.32 percent per year in transaction costs over and above the other expenses listed for a fund, according to Bogle.

In order to be a successful mutual fund investor, you need to be aware of not only the return on your funds but equally important, the costs associated with your funds. That means that when researching mutual funds, if the returns are the same for the funds you are interested in, look for the fund with the lower turnover rate. After all, at the end of the day, it’s about not how much your fund made, it’s about how much you got to keep after expenses.

As for whether there are specific funds that I can recommend because they have lower expenses, the short answer is yes. But which ones would depend on your individual situation. What should you stay away from? That’s a little more difficult because that depends on your entire portfolio and your individual goals. (If you’d like a free report of mutual fund expenses, call 310-587-3370 or e-mail at, and reference this article. Rob Jupille is the president of RTJ Financial in Santa Monica.)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 14, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe