Skip to content

The living wage will not bring about Armageddon

Published:

By Joel C. Koury

Santa Monica has been under attack for the last four years by a well armed and lavishly financed special interest that wants to end our local democracy. A handful of mega-rich, multinational corporations are upset because they cannot rule our city like Sacramento or Washington D.C.

In those cities, those with the most money get to write the law. These corporations, and their lawyers and lobbyists, cannot believe that our local officials would really put the public interest above their bottom line. So now that our officials have shown that they cannot be bought, the corporate money is betting on slick pre-packaged campaigns to pull one over on the voters.

Four years ago, seeing that our city was studying raising the minimum wage, these corporations banded together and spent over $1 million pushing a law, Measure KK that would have prevented the city from increasing the minimum wage forever. In the last week of that campaign, when their polls showed that the voters saw through their deceptive campaign, the proponents switched gears and diverted their money to trying to get a slate of candidates elected to the city council to try and kill a higher minimum wage law before it was even enacted. Despite the last minute infusion of tens of thousands of dollars of hotel industry money, Robert Holbrook and Herb Katz were the only ones from this anti-living wage slate to get elected.

These super-rich corporations would not be deterred by past failures, so they passed their hat and raised millions more. This time they decided to fight the living wage on two fronts. First they sponsored and came up with the VERITAS initiative, Measure HH. This little gem would split the city into different districts thereby consolidating most renters into one district so their voices would be muted.

And then to virtually silence them, this initiative would strip all of us of our right to vote for all seven members of the city council. Instead we would be limited to voting for only one council member and a mayor, who would have veto power over the city council. This way our super rich friends can spend a few thousand per district to stack the city council and prevent any future bothersome laws like a reasonable wage for employees from ever being enacted.

Of course they have also devoted another million to fight the real living wage law, Measure JJ. Before I get to their false and dishonest claims, let’s review what the living wage proposition will actually do.

If a business is located on the boardwalk or in the downtown zone, and that business makes over $5 million per year, they must pay their employees a minimum wage of $10.50. If a business is not in that zone or does not make that much per year, the law does not apply to them.

Even if a business makes over $5 million a year, there is an exemption if the higher wage would cause a financial hardship. The law does not affect charities, nonprofits, the Boys and Girls club or even small businesses.

This living wage mostly applies to the billion-dollar multinational corporations that own the luxury hotels on the beach and their 2000 employees. The bus boys, waiters, and maids who clean the toilets in the $6,000 per night luxury suites at places like the Loew’s Hotel would get a raise of about $150 per week.

So let’s go through some of the arguments they raise in their letters and brochures and see if their arguments can withstand a common sense analysis.

Discriminatory application: This word is used five times in the letter with the city logo that was mailed by Herb Katz to my house. Only by reading the fine print do you discover that it was actually paid for by the hotel industry’s political action committee — the same PAC that brought us the old bogus Measure KK, VERI- TAS, and Herb Katz.

His claim is that it discriminates by requiring some businesses to pay this wage but not all businesses. Time to use a little common sense. Of course, it would be nice if all businesses paid a living wage but the little dry cleaner that hires a teenager to stack laundry cannot afford it because they do not make as much money as Loew’s Hotel. But the dry cleaner will not have to pay a higher wage. Is it too much to ask for a super rich business to pay more than a little business? Should a janitor pay the same in taxes as Bill Gates? The law is fair and reasonable because it distinguishes between those businesses that can afford to pay more, from those that cannot.

As for as the difference in pay scale based on location, the city has spent millions each year to develop and maintain the Promenade and the boardwalk. These corporations are lawfully taking advantage of these improvements and their location to charge higher rates to the tourists who come to stay in these prime spots. Last time I checked, the motel on Ocean Park and 20th does not have anyone paying $6,000 per night for a suite like the Loew’s Hotel. The businesses are not equally situated and any first year law student can tell you that is why it is not discriminatory.

The winner in the chutzpah award, of course, goes to the argument in the fliers and Mr. Katz’s letter that the city will have to spend millions defending this law in court. Well, I have a simple response to Mr. Katz and the businesses that hired him. If you are really concerned about saving the city money, then don’t sue if the law gets enacted! This argument is nothing more than blackmail and while it may be legal, it sure is not moral or honest.

There are a hodgepodge of other arguments that have been posted lately in your paper by letter writers or in the mailers. The city will lose jobs. Loew’s is not going to hire anyone to clean the toilets in their rooms because thousand-dollar-per-night-guests don’t demand clean rooms and linens. We will hire less people and the city will lose jobs. As if Ocean Avenue Seafood has dozens of people standing around getting paid who do nothing.

I am voting for Proposition JJ because companies which reap the benefits of city expenditures that make this a world class tourist destination spot, should be required to pay the woman cleaning the toilets in the luxury suite a wage that is above the poverty line. Likewise, I am voting against Proposition HH because I do not want my city council to be taken over by the same kind of special interest lobbyists that control the term-limited Sacramento legislators. And for good measure I will always vote against Herb Katz and Robert Holbrook for any office, and it will be a cold day in hell before I patronize Ocean Avenue Seafood, Loew’s, or Shutters on the Beach.

It’s time that for us to protect the public interest from the special interest money.

Joel C. Koury is a Santa Monica resident.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 5, 2002. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe