Skip to content

The merits of Prop. A: Developer’s dream or a preservationist’s nightmare?

Published:

By Todd Flora

■ In 26 years, the Landmarks Commission has created ONE historic district. Only 16 homes have been designated landmarks. And yet we will soon go to the ballot box in Santa Monica because there is apparently a HUGE crisis facing homeowners.

Some will probably try and tell you money is being wasted to run Proposition A because the City Council didn’t heed the concerns of 9,000 petitioners. I would argue that the city is spending more than $100,000 to conduct the Proposition A election because conservative land use attorneys saw dollar signs and forced the issue, and the city didn’t cower to their threats.

Proposition A is a political tool more than a policy issue. Conservative forces in Santa Monica are using this measure as another organizing device in their quest to crush all things progressive here.

Sure, proponents of Proposition A, which would strip the city of any power to preserve historic spaces, got their necessary amount of signatures (among them are many unwitting accomplices). And there is no question that homeowners should expect certain private property rights. Yet the proponents of this reactionary measure knocked down the doors of City Hall as if aliens had landed, and threatened the City Council by saying “an electoral giant” was “coming after” them.

Well pardon me, but with 16 houses dedicated as landmarks in 26 YEARS, isn’t this a little like an arsonist coming to the fire station to demand that if his blaze isn’t put out fast, there will be hell to pay?

Enter Tom Larmore, a property rights attorney and Santa Monica’s “conservative consigliere.” He is a very articulate true believer who fights for big hotel owners, big developers, and now Proposition A. He even had the audacity to compare this homeowner’s rights issue to the reproductive rights movement in a recent Daily Press guest editorial piece. The comparison is offensive at best.

Mr. Larmore makes money representing people who buy up land to build on it. That’s not necessarily bad. My dad works for developers too. But make no mistake — Larmore and friends MANUFACTURED this historic districts crisis. I’m not saying no homeowner has suffered unnecessarily at the hands of City Hall. I’ve heard stories. But ask yourself who financially benefits from forcing this issue? Who could make a decent hourly rate fighting for those who would tear down existing homes to build out to the property line? Friends, who REALLY has the city wasting $100,000 to run this election? (Todd Flora has served as personal assistant to then Lt. Gov., Gray Davis, and state director for the California Clean Money Campaign. He is a professional issues manager who has been featured on TV, radio, and in several publications. To respond or to reach Todd, ).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 11, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe