Skip to content

The new American anti-semitism on display

Published:

By INCITES BY ED SILVERSTEIN

From beneath Stetson brims, squinting against the smoke drifting from dangled cigarettes, steely gazes follow the progress of a curly headed figure carrying a guitar, almost daring him to step onto the stage of this Tucson Country Western bar. Scant applause follows the introduction of Barat, a television host from Kazakhstan.

Nervously, in broken English, he informs the unwelcoming beer-swilling crowd that he will sing a song about the problems in his country. He sings, in a nasally twang, inane lyrics concerning how the transportation is slow in his country because Kazakhstan is big. The crowd begins to eye him as if he had just set fire to an American flag.

But in the next instant, as Barot sings his second verse, he finds his voice. And just like that, the crowd is his.

“In my country there is problem,” he sings. “And that problem is the Jew. They take everybody’s money. They never give it back.” The audience begins to perk up. “Throw the Jew down the well. So my country can be free.” A guy loudly echoes, “SO MY COUNTRY CAN BE FREE.” “You must grab them by the horns. And have a big par-ty.”

International relations — at least as far as these Tucson cowboy wannabes are concerned — have just taken a giant leap forward. And when Barot hits the next chorus of “Throw the Jew down the well,” the crowd is clapping to the beat, singing right along and wagging their fingers alongside their temples as if they had horns.

What the crowd does not know is that Barat is none other than Jewish comedian Sasha Cohen. Cohen is the creative force and star behind the hit HBO series, Da Ali “G” Show, in which he takes on various personas in elaborate practical jokes designed to ridicule ignorance and extremism.

But watching this particular episode, while I appreciated Cohen’s sardonic antics, I couldn’t help feeling disturbed by the ease and enthusiasm in which the crowd participated.

Anti-semitism has experienced a cataclysmic rise throughout the world. A recent study showed a dramatic increase in attacks against Jews in Europe, specifically Belgium, France, Germany, the Netherlands and Britain. And though Muslims share much of the blame the main culprits, according to the BBC, are young, disaffected white Europeans.

These increased attacks are not surprising when you take into account that Jews have been victimized by a campaign of lies and propaganda every bit as vicious and scurrilous as the Swift Boat Commanders attacks against Kerry. The Arab media spews out a never-ending stream of hate that has blamed Israel and the Jews for everything from the war in Iraq to 9/11. Anti-semitic Internet sites have increased by 300 percent. The main-stream media, while better, seems unable to extricate itself from the anti-Israel bias perpetrated by a UN that has allowed the dialog on the Israeli/Palestinian conflict to be hijacked by extremist Muslim countries.

But through it all, America seemed to remain an island of reason. Growing up, and until recently, I could count the anti-semitic remarks on one hand and still have a finger left to flip off anyone who said something in the future.

This is not to say that I wasn’t aware that anti-semitism existed. My father, when he was held in a German prisoner of war camp, experienced more anti-semitism from his fellow American soldiers than his Nazi guards. And America has historically produced bumper crops of ignorance.

But for the past several decades, thanks to the civil rights movement of the ’60s and the Vatican II that renounced many entrenched anti-Jewish beliefs, such hatred had dissipated. A majority of Americans even elected a Jewish vice president in the last election. But all of this is beginning to change.

Some of the fault goes to bigoted right wing pundits, such as Rush Limbaugh, who blame all of America’s moral ills on “those Jews who control Hollywood,” even as they canonize Republicans who have made a religion of dirty tricks and breaking the rules.

Mel Gibson’s film, “The Passion,” a sadistic and brutal portrayal of the crucifixion, also deserves blame for this rise of hatred. Gibson egregiously ignores the historical record and the advice of theological scholars by depicting the Jewish priests as the architects of Christ’s murder rather than servants doing the dirty work of Rome. Gibson, who is the son of a rabid anti-semite, has stated that all Jews will go to Hell.

President Bush, who has pushed a Christian first agenda, also has made the statement that all Jews will go to Hell, as have many of the Christian right politicians that support him.

And while Limbaugh’s bigoted stereotyping, Gibson’s Jew bashing and Bush’s Christian chauvinism might only provoke a few direct attacks against Jews, it makes it more acceptable to openly denigrate the Jewish people.

And dredging up long rejected allegations that the Jews killed Jesus and the insistence, no matter how gravely or reluctantly stated, that all Jews are going to Hell, creates a mind set in which Jews are cast as villains.

It is time for President Bush and other American leaders to divorce themselves from such insensitive and inflammatory talk. It is far too similar to accounts describing the early rhetoric of the Nazi party, which eventually took the lives of 6 million Jews. And while I would like to believe that a bunch of liquored up crap-kickers from Tucson are not capable of genocide, neither did I believe that America would sanction torture.

Maybe I’m being paranoid. But if you read the memoirs of Holocaust survivors, there is one universal theme: They all knew it couldn’t happen there. (Ed Silverstein lives in Santa Monica. Comments or requests for copies of this column can be e-mailed to).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 22, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe