Skip to content

The political fight is in the wild, wild West

Published:

By HERE’S THE THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D

Good news on the campaign trail — the candidates have finally begun to recognize that the real battleground is not the “rust belt,” but instead the western frontier.

According to Nick Anderson’s report in the Los Angeles Times on Tuesday, both Kerry and Bush have continued spending money in New Mexico and started spending money in Nevada. Bush also has starting spending in Colorado and Arizona. Of course, each campaign is spending in more states across the country, but these changes reflect a new understanding of the race.

For most of this election, both candidates have been veritably entrenched in Ohio, Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Michigan and Wisconsin. Both campaigns have held to a core belief that the entire presidential election hinged on the way these states would swing.

While they are probably right about the importance of these states from a numerical standpoint (Electoral College vote count), they are very likely wrong in believing that these states would swing much further beyond their recent electoral history.

Swinging requires the electorate to move from one party to another. It requires change. Electorates can only change in two ways: Either people change (individuals switch parties), or the demographic make-up of the electorate changes (groups change in relative proportion to each other).

In the five battleground states in the “rust belt,” the only change that has occurred has been a continued shrinking of the electorate as people leave these states for warmer climates. Ohio, Pennsylvania, West Virginia, Michigan and Wisconsin lost five Electoral College votes between them in the last reapportionment. For the individuals who have remained in those states, I’m doubtful that change of any kind is on their list of solutions to the increasing number of challenges that are facing them and their communities.

Yet, the campaigns believed that the conditions in these states — the poor economy, the high unemployment rates and the feelings of insecurity — would motivate the electorate to behave differently. They expected Ohioans and Pennsylvanians alike to vote opposite from their vote in the previous election. They expected the people to change.

Might as well ask them to move states. Change is a high-risk strategy. You must be a good salesman to be able to sell change. Neither candidate is that great of a salesman. Kerry is no Clinton and Bush is no Reagan. Probably was-n’t such a smart strategy.

Where should the campaigns have focused their attention? Where they are finally starting to look now, and where the 2000 census told them to focus all along — the West.

In the reapportionment, Nevada, Arizona and Colorado gained four Electoral College votes, and their populations are still growing. According to a report by Texas A&M Professor Rogelio Saenz, Colorado, New Mexico and Arizona are three of the 10 states in the U.S. that have the largest Latino population, and Nevada is one of 10 states with the fastest growing Latino population.

This is important because for many Latinos, partisanship is not yet firmly rooted. Many are new voters — some are even new citizens. If the parties are going to spend resources working to persuade voters, then they should be working in places of opportunity.

In Colorado alone, out of the 3.2 million citizens who are over 18, there are 435,000 Latinos. According to a recent poll, they prefer Kerry to Bush 54 percent to 31 percent. Kerry has an enormous opportunity in Colorado, yet he isn’t even spending money there. Granted, this likely has to do with their ballot proposition, which makes the effort futile because even if Kerry won the state, he might only win five of the nine Electoral College votes. Still, the Democratic Party should work to defeat the proposition and build a voting block in Colorado that would vote Democratic for years to come.

Currently, the candidates are tied within the margin of error in most state polls (Nevada, Colorado and New Mexico). There has been movement back and forth between the candidates all summer long. The only state that appears out of reach for Kerry at the moment is Arizona, where Bush is leading in most polls by about 10 points.

You can’t spend your time fighting the last campaign. Gore lost West Virginia and Ohio, and Kerry seems convinced that if he just wins those states, the election is his. Meanwhile, Bush wants to repeat his wins, and add on some of the blue Midwest (Michigan and Wisconsin).

But like the debate about which candidate did what during Vietnam, it’s long since over. Move on. Fight the battle in front of you — whether it’s Iraq, the economy, or the western frontier and the changing American electorate. If you stay stuck in the past, you’ll soon be history. (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is a political scientist from Los Angeles, and is teaching this semester in Arkansas, at Hendrix College and UALR. She)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 23, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe