Skip to content

The real deal on 18th Street

Published:

Editor:

Bea Nemlaha (Feb. 7, 2003, Daily Press) has absolutely no right to speak for the people of 18th Street, since she clearly has no idea what happened here, or any sense of the emotions and prevailing attitudes of the people who live here (which generated Proposition A). She makes a serious blunder by attempting to rewrite our recent history.

When our neighbor, Marc Schrobilgen, attempted to get a demolition permit for his house, one person complained to the Landmarks Commission, which subsequently froze his property under its draconian “structure of merit” designation. Over 75 of his neighbors came to the commission in Marc’s defense, presenting them and the City Council with WRITTEN opposition to what they were doing to him. We attended their meetings and asked them to release him, and they refused. Our frustration grew, and as we realized that any one of us could be next, the result was Proposition A.

The suggestion that Marc was a developer who was stopped by “concerned” 18th Street neighbors is a complete misrepresentation. His neighbors supported him in overwhelming numbers, and this is very well documented in the city record. If anything, his case proves that under the current law an individual homeowner can be grievously harmed by the will of a few, even if he enjoys the support of the majority of the community. The arguments repeated in Bea Nemlaha’s letter are not the arguments of the people of 18th Street.

They are the arguments of the Landmarks Commission, an UN-ELECTED bureaucracy which is trying desperately to hang on to its ability to hurt citizens like Marc, while disregarding the wishes of his neighbors in the face of an overwhelming popular uprising against them.

They are the arguments of organizations from outside Santa Monica, such as the Los Angeles Conservancy, who are making an incursion into our city to attempt to defeat the people’s initiative.

They are the arguments of one side of the inhabitants of the Third Street Historic District, where a small group of people can prevent a neighbor from adding a garage because they have a personal grudge against her. Believe me, the citizen in question (who still has nowhere to park) has a completely different view of life in a city-run, committee-controlled district.

They are, perhaps, the arguments of the Landmarks Commissioner who lives on 18th Street, who extensively remodeled his house at exactly the same time that Marc was being denied his permit a few doors down. Yes, this really happened.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 13, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe