Skip to content

The real story on war

Published:

By Jean-Michel Boulay Los Angeles

The problem with the evidence presented by Colin Powell to the U.N. Security Council is that is not verifiable. This should not be a problem if you trust the government, but you have to remember that the U.S. government manufactured evidence before to whip up support for unpopular wars, notably for the first Gulf war. The testimony at the U.N. about Iraqi soldiers throwing babies out of incubators during the Kuwait invasion in 1990 was a big lie: The “witness” was the daughter of the Kuwaiti Ambassador in the U.S. and had been coached by PR firm Hill & Knowlton to lie convincingly. Knowing this, the tape recordings presented by Colin Powell become especially dubious, as he mentioned neither the identities of the people who allegedly were recorded, nor the time of the call nor the phone numbers involved. You could produce a similar tape where two Pentagon “officials” would be discussing U.S. plans to drop nuclear bombs on the capital of every country that opposes the coming war: All you need is two people speaking into the appropriate equipment with the right accents.

Why does the government mention human rights violations as a reason to go to war now when it chose to ignore them in the ‘80s, and why is it still ignoring human rights violations in Turkey (who is also persecuting Kurds on its territory)? And if the government is so concerned about the welfare of the Iraqi people, why are the economic sanctions still in place?

Finally, from a weapons of mass destruction standpoint, North Korea is far more dangerous than Iraq. North Korea is known to be selling missiles around the world (most recently to Yemen in January) to generate revenue and has the technology to produce nuclear weapons. As such, they are the most likely candidates to supply terrorist groups with weapons of mass destruction if they can get a good price for it. North Korea has kicked out inspectors of the International Atomic Energy Agency and refuses further inspections.

President Bush claims that Iraq has to be taken care of through war now, but that North Korea should be dealt with peacefully. Pakistan too appears more dangerous to Iraq: It has nuclear weapons and supports radical Islamic movements (it supported the Taliban in Afghanistan and is accused of harboring terrorist groups that attack Kashmir). Yet Pakistan is presented as an ally.

The government probably has good reasons to go to war, but chances are these reasons are the ones we’re being told.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on February 17, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe