By Yehuda Leibman Santa Monica
I would like to humbly offer this in balance to the letters to the editor by Liz Peel and John Marciano (SMDP, Nov. 10, page 4), as those both clearly contribute to the hate that already exists.
Everyone is entitled to his or her opinion, however anti-Semitic, excuse me, anti- Israeli it is. But by misrepresenting the facts, a distorted picture of reality is produced.
Let’s take a closer looks on the fact presented. Palestinian Post was published 1932-1950, i.e. during the times of a British Mandate over the Palestine, before the Israel was established as a country in 1948. Just to clarify the fact presented by Liz Peel, and not to dispute in any way the issues of Palestinian national identity, the Jews published it.
Liz Peel listed all Jewish organizations that are probably known to her. A majority of these groups were created and acted for the purpose of self-defense, such as to guard settlements or in response to the mass massacre of Jews in Hebron, provoked by the mufti, who was a supporter and a friend of Hitler. Some indeed where involved in terrorism, or were “freedom fighters” as we call it today. A guerrilla warfare was against British occupational forces, which blocked the Jewish survivals of the Holocaust from entering the Palestine. There was a blown up hotel occupied by the military staff and hanged British sergeants. I’ve never heard of a public bus bombing or sniper killing of the children by any of these groups.
In every nation, even if it is a Jewish one, there are people who have opinions or beliefs that are different from those of the majority. It is true that there are religious sects that believe that it is Mashiah’s (Messiah) job to restore the Kingdom of Israel.
The kingdom, and not the modern state. They are very few and relatively isolated. I seriously doubt any one of them was ever in Durban marching alongside Palestinians. Liz Peel is absolutely right to guess, that “there are Jewish people who are tired of their faith being used.” This is especially true relating to those like herself who posses neither knowledge nor understanding of the complicated matter. So, exactly who is lying?
Another lie is to claim that Israel is not a member of UN. Just the fact that the state of Israel was established by the UN resolution. Israel has its ambassador there. I am not sure that anywhere in the world, even in Israel, bumper stickers ever express an official government policy. But, what about the UN’s failures of many years to prevent numerous attack against Israel? Failure to prevent wars launched by neighboring Arabs states — why forget it’s perpetuated by the Soviet block unbalanced pro-Arab position? It is not widely publicized fact, however, that not that long ago several UN “peace workers” were caught transporting terrorist missiles. Yes, think of Iran or Iraq or Libya and all the other countries that now preside over the UN’s Human Rights commission. Yes, please give it some thought.
In her list, Liz Peel missed many intelligence organizations that use Israel as training ground — KGB, East German Shtazi and Romanian Segurantsa, Iranian, etc. — they all trained terrorists to act there. Some of these students studied alongside me in Moscow. Unfortunately, that’s all I know. The same goes to the nuclear program. I guess Liz Peel would not reduce herself to a plain libel and surely has a hard evidences. Perhaps truth will come forward. That’s my prayer.
There are young and not so young people who refuse to serve in Israel military. And there are many of those who will think of this service as a big honor. People are tired of this cycle of violence. No one likes a war. Never in my life I’ve met an Israeli parent who wanted his 18-year-old son or daughter to be drafted in the army instead of going to a university. When John Marciano in his letter quotes the number of killed Palestinian children versus Israeli ones, he somehow omits the fact that Israeli children were killed by terrorist attacks, while many Palestinian minors became victims during the clashes with the army and police. Please understand me correctly — any child should be protected in any possible way. This double standard, even when using the numbers, only helps to play down the responsibility of those who send children to harms way. It is them who are the real terrorists.
There is no secret that Hamas received funding from Israel. I think it still receives some. This funding was for the hospitals, schools and social programs that Hamas runs. Does Liz Peel have any evidence of misuse? I guess in this situation, any honest person should alarm everyone about it, no matter Muslim, Jew, Christian or follower of Christ.
I am not sure what a “fight” between Sephardic and Ashkenazic Jews has to do with the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Israel is a “melting pot” as is this country, with many immigrants, and clearly there are tensions between people of different cultures and backgrounds. And this is normal to any society. In this country we also have many social, ethnic and cultural tensions, even, as I learned from the letter, between the “Christian right” and the “follower of the Christ.” And this country is the greatest democracy in the world. Israel is a democracy as well. Is there any other country in the world where the Arab member of the Knesset (parliament) could openly call for the destruction of the state in which Parliament he seats?
Right of Return is the law that guarantees any Jew in any corner of the world at any time a right to go to Israel and to be protected by this state. Law of Return was adopted as a result of the world’s silence during the Holocaust. It helped to save and still saves the lives of thousands of people, and by itself is an important reason for existence of the state of Israel. When Iron Curtain collapsed, I went to study in Paris and after the Soviet Union could not even imagine that such freedom and democracy could exist. The family that hosted me traced its French routes to a Napoleon soldier. Recently they abandoned everything and moved to Israel because of the fear for their safety in a free France.
Not that much time passed here since Charles Lindbergh gathered crowds of thousands on his fascist meetings, or after the refugee passengers of the “Saint Louis” were not allowed to disembark in Miami and were sent back to the gas chambers. Give it now some thought of what Right of Return does to “Jews from all over the world who are or have been intelligence in their own countries.”
Give it now some thought about the Christian baby blood libel or “Protocols of Zion Elders.” Aren’t those pathological accusations of the same sort? Strange that Liz Peel did not bring it up.
I respect the freedom of speech for everyone. Unfortunately, when I see that newspapers give the tribune to “not anti-Semitic” letters like the one by Liz Peel, I feel that the deadly “spirit of Saint Louis” is still alive, and I am getting scared. And I will fight so no one to be forced to exercise the Right of Return.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 12, 2004. Read the original PDF.