By Gerald Jones Santa Monica
Regarding Tom Babbitt’s letter (SMDP, Aug. 16, page 4), “Dog days of summer don’t include canines,” the lengthy discussion of impervious surfaces and runoff is irrelevant to an objective assessment of whether an off-leash dog zone on the beach will contribute to further pollution of the bay. There are some 50 other dog beaches on the California coast, and water samples collected from them, including nearby Long Beach, show that water quality is not affected by the presence of a dog zone.
The question of an “unfenced” dog zone is far from settled. Dog guardians do not oppose fencing off the zone. Rather, the opposition to fencing is from government agencies. Long Beach is a good example of a compromise. Trash cans stenciled “dog beach” are placed at the perimeters of the zone, and the borders are further marked by rows of orange highway cones. Regulations require dogs to be on-leash as they are led to and from the zone.
As Unleash the Beach (UTB) stated before a recent meeting of the California State Recreation and Parks Commission, we believe that permitting a dog zone in relatively limited area bounded by lifeguard stands 11 and 12 will both enhance public enjoyment of the beach and will actually improve environmental quality in that area. This is an underutilized portion of the beach, mostly because it has a storm drain at its center. UTB has been monitoring the area for the past few months, when the storm drain is dammed up for the summer season. Frankly, the area is filthy. UTB proposes that any pilot program for a dog zone there include redoubled efforts at cleaning the storm drain. As an organization, we are prepared to do our part to make sure that happens.
And, that’s all that’s being proposed — a pilot program — which would be there for any concerned citizen to observe, as well as for public comment when the City Council reviews the pilot experience.
Furthermore, as UTB stated before the commission, drawing dog guardians and their pets to that underutilized area of the beach should have a further positive effect on environmental quality. If usage follows the experience of other dog beaches, responsible dog guardians will not only pick up after their own pets, but, not wanting the dogs to go after any food refuse they find, they also tend to throw any such refuse into the trash bins. As a result, the beach is cleaner, and the seabird population, which is there primarily to dine on food refuse, is less prevalent in the area. As a result, bird guano, also a potential pollutant of the water, should be reduced in that area.
Some folks say it’s all about poop, but the data from other dog beaches show otherwise. There would be few complaints if the populations of dolphins or seals were increasing in our bay, which would result in an inevitable increase in mammalian feces in the water. The difference with increasing the dog population at the beach is that the dogs have caring humans to pick up after them.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 24, 2005. Read the original PDF.