Skip to content

The sometimes courageous act of switching parties

Published:

By HERE’S THE THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D

U.S. Representative Rodney Alexander last week surprised not only members of the Democratic Party, but also the constituents in his Louisiana district by switching his party affiliation from Democratic to Republican when he registered for the Nov. 2 election on the last day of ballot qualification.

His action was such a shocker because in his initial filing — on Wednesday of the same of week — he had declared himself a Democrat. By waiting until Friday to announce his partisan switch, he made sure that the Democratic Party would not be able to run a candidate against him. Come November, Rep. Alexander who has only served one term in the House will be the only viable candidate on the ballot — from either party.

Rep. Alexander justified his switch by saying that he would be “more effective” for his district as a Republican, noting that he has been a conservative Democrat who is “pro-life and pro-Second Amendment” rights.

Democratic Sen. Mary Landrieu referred to his act as “cowardly,” and said: “Nobody likes a coward, least of all Louisiana voters.”

Meanwhile, President Bush called Alexander and “welcomed” him to the GOP.

Was this a courageous act or a cowardly maneuver? In politics, it’s often tough to tell virtue from vice. Many acts that appear courageous have self-interest as their motive, and many acts that appear conciliatory (to some, cowardly) require courage because they involve trusting others.

Switching parties is not a small decision. Most elected officials who switch explain that their old party no longer represents their philosophical beliefs. Usually, that elected official’s voting record shows that the individual has voted more often with the opposition party than with their own party. They talk of how they remained loyal until they could no longer go against their own conscience.

The party that is left often feels betrayed and usually runs a strong (well-financed and well-known) candidate against that elected official, almost out of what appears to be spite. The party that the elected official joins, while they are pleased to have them in their ranks, are not completely sure about how much they can trust them, and often that elected official finds himself cut “out of the loop.”

Switching parties is a huge political risk for an elected official, and often they will be an outsider for a long-time to come unless they can show the party they are joining, that they have value enough to make them an insider. Switching parties probably should be viewed as a courageous act.

There are times, however, when one wonders about the motive and the courage of the elected official. Those times include, when individuals switch their party affiliation after the majority control switches, as occurred with a few members after the 1994 election in the House. Those switches tend to smack of political expediency, even if they still took courage to execute.

Two Southern Democratic Representatives from Louisiana, Jimmy Hayes and Billy Tauzin, both became Republicans in 1995. Hayes lost in his runoff election in 1996, but Tauzin won, and quickly became part of the Republican leadership. He now serves as Deputy Majority Whip for the GOP, though he is retiring at the end of this session.

Were Hayes and Tauzin sincere? Were they representing their districts, being courageous leaders, or being self-interested politicians who wanted to ensure their own seats at the table when the Republicans came into power in the House? The answer is probably all of the above.

Both men were conservative Democrats. Both men, given the philosophical drift of the Republican Party toward the Religious Right, likely felt more comfortable aligned with Republicans than with the Democrats.

So, was it necessarily wrong for them to want to be in more powerful positions than less?

No. We should hope that our representatives would all strive to be in more powerful positions because that means they would be able to do more work on our behalf. The difference in the two men is that Tauzin more accurately understood the partisan leanings of his district, his personal support, and his competition, whereas, Hayes did not, which is why he lost.

Rep. Alexander’s party switching took courage to do — even if it was awful to behold. He betrayed everyone who helped get him elected to office, including Sens. Landrieu, Breaux, and the entire Louisiana Democratic Party.

It only seems cowardly because he was blatantly disloyal and obviously political in his maneuvering through the electoral process. While he may lose his reelection bid because he may have lost the trust of his constituents, like Hayes, we cannot begrudge him for being political. He is a politician.

Though he may come to discover that in politics, defiance is often judged to be more cowardly than compromise. (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is a political scientist from Los Angeles, and is teaching this semester in Arkansas, at Hendrix College and UALR. She).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on August 12, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe