By HERE’S THE THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D
Over this past weekend, it was confirmed that the top political advisor to President Bush, Karl Rove, was the source of the leak to Time Magazine reporter Matthew Cooper on the identity of covert CIA agent Valerie Plame. The Republicans — not surprisingly — are defending Rove and calling this a “liberal smear campaign.” The Democrats — not surprisingly — are demonizing Rove and calling for his resignation, at the very least. The Bush Administration is silent, pleading that it is “an ongoing investigation.”
Personally, I want answers. This has been going on for two years — since Robert Novak revealed Valerie Plame’s identity in his column on July 14, 2003. It’s time for truth to come out.
First, the simple questions: ■ Where did Rove get the information about Plame being a covert CIA operative? It’s not information that just hangs around the White House or on the campaign trail. ■ Why did Rove want to discredit and “punish” former Ambassador Joseph Wilson so much? Republicans don’t read the New York Times because they tend to think it is a “liberal rag sheet,” which is why I find it hard to believe that he or anyone in the White House would have cared that much about his op-ed on July 6, 2003. What made them so upset? Was it the message or the messenger? ■ When exactly did Rove tell Bush about his communication(s) with Cooper? Bush’s statement on Wednesday when he didn’t come out directly in support of Rove in combination with Bush’s earlier comments about “firing” whomever was involved in the leaking leads me to believe that Rove did not tell Bush the whole truth when the story broke two years ago. Protecting his boss (plausible deniability), covering his hide, or someone else’s hide?
Next, the more tricky ones: ■ Novak cited “two senior administration officials” in his column. If we assume that Rove was one, then who was the other? Has anyone asked? ■ Cooper received a waiver of confidentiality from his source (Rove), and with that Cooper then agreed to testify before the grand jury, which he did on Wednesday. New York Times reporter Judith Miller, however, has not received a waiver from her source. Thus, she is currently in jail, protecting his/her confidentiality. This leads me to believe that Miller’s source was different from Cooper’s source. If Rove had been Miller’s source, then wouldn’t he have also granted Miller a waiver? Who is Miller protecting? Is it possible that the person she is protecting knows more than Rove? That he/she was the one who told Rove about Plame? ■ Novak must have worked out some kind of deal, allowing him to testify in the investigation, given that he is not facing any legal battles over this issue. Does this mean then that he received waivers from both of his sources? And if so, then is this the reason why the special prosecutor worked so hard to get Cooper and Miller’s testimony? So that he would not have to rely on anything that Novak said? Wouldn’t this be a way to exonerate a well-known and loyal conservative Republican columnist, while at the same time, setting up two liberal scribes in his final report?
Here’s The Thing: For months, it’s been bothering me why the White House took the time to attack Newsweek reporter Michael Isikoff last May over his Koran desecration story at the Guantánamo Bay detention facility. Lots of people had written about it, but Newsweek took the heat.
It appears that the White House knew then, what I suspect now.
Michael Isikoff knows who both sources are in the CIA leak story, and the still anonymous source is higher up than Rove. Why? Because Isikoff was the first one out of the box with an in-depth story on Rove’s communications with Cooper after Time turned over materials to the grand jury. He has also written articles about the people who were most involved with the issues that brought on the op-ed and the leak. When the whole story is told, it would not be surprising to find, if at least half of it, relates to what Isikoff already wrote about in November of 2003 (see: http://msnbc.msn.com/id/3403519/). (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D.)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 15, 2005. Read the original PDF.