Skip to content

The truth will set you free, or at least out of trouble

Published:

By IN LA BY HEIDI MANTEUFFEL

01568589 The whole truth and nothing but truth is a cute thing to say on the witness stand, but it doesn’t always hold true in real life. To be honest, it probably doesn’t hold true in cheesy court drama, either.

You don’t have to be in a court of law to know that telling your girlfriend she’s becoming her mother could get you capital punishment. It will at least give you an hour of “That’s not what I’m saying, baby,” which will be shortly followed by two hours of “I don’t consider you as a derogatory object. That’s not what I meant at all …”

Of course, nothing but the truth is the way I usually roll with my day, but you gotta admit, some things are better left unsaid.

If people want to know the truth, they’ll ask you for it. That is, unless they’re a stressed out/worried woman. Then asking can mean either tell me the truth, or, this is a test of the emergency broadcast system. Beep.

The emergency comes when you can’t think of how to correctly answer her inquiries about the issues she’s most sensitive about.

In this case, if you think she actually wants to hear your opinion on the matter — don’t be fooled — she doesn’t. But have no fear, the questions are conveniently set up for your failure. To help get you out of the combative situations alive, though, I’ll give you some warning signs from a fellow trouble-searching feline.

You are at an open mic coffeehouse and your girlfriend has just sung her heart out with her brand new guitar. Her singing was off, her lyrics first grade at best, and you couldn’t tell if the notes she plucked were actual cords. After a few sympathy claps by other people in the audience, she sits down next to you cheery eyed, asking how she did.

Rule 1: Girlfriends are always talented, even if in reality they are not.

Don’t hesitate for a second to respond — you know how she did — amazing. She was so amazing and she looked great doing it. Sure, she kind of hurt your eardrums and was so off that some bloodhounds outside started barking.

Well, maybe that’s only happened to me.

But answering in this fashion is not lying. Well … it’s nothing a mom would-n’t do for her first grade ice-skating hopeful with a frozen snot-laden face who keeps falling over from the blasted toe pick. Wait — maybe that’s just me again.

Here’s another type of phrase that’s bound to ensue. “My brother can be so annoying at times,” she says infuriated. Ah, I can see you start to nod in agreement but don’t do it. He might have poor taste in girlfriends he finds at comic book conventions, a three-foot long soul patch and terrible foot odor that you’ve wanted to bag on for so long, but now is not the time to chime in.

Rule 2: Don’t ever agree to anything negative that has to do with her family. It’s OK for her to rip on her brother, but if you agree, she’ll take it as a personal affront. Picking on the family is picking on her, and soon she’ll be calling love patch Louis and telling him you hate his comic-con girlfriend.

Lastly there’s the “Do you think I’ve put on a few pounds?” type of inquiry. Now, anything with the word “pound” in it that does not refer to cake is a clear omen that danger is ahead. Retreat, retreat … I would even scamper out of the room if possible.

Rule 3: Plead the fifth on all questions that have to do with weight.

No matter how many times she asks you to tell her your “honest” opinion, don’t give it. Tell her that she looks great, wonderful. Keep affirming the positive.

This question is definitely quicksand, a lose-lose situation. Your only hope in this scenario is to make it out of the apartment with as few battle wounds as possible. You can even pull the I’m-a-guy card, and hadn’t really noticed. This is the one case where it’s OK to be male and unobservant.

Don’t get the idea that it’s OK to veil the truth. I’m not talking about deliberately hiding the fact that you jacked up her disposal by pouring 20 pounds of Ranch dressing down it because you wanted to find the Hidden Valley. That will get you into a whole other mess of trouble.

I’m just saying that some things in life are better left unsaid. If she really wants to know how well she did on her solo, don’t be a jerk — do it in the kindest and nicest way possible. Tell her who cares if the bloodhounds are now running towards your table ready to pummel her to the ground. You know that she poured her heart into it, and to tell the truth, that’s all that really matters. (Heidi)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 15, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe