By Bill Bauer (Bill Bauer is a longtime Santa Monica resident and freelance writer).
The defeat on Wednesday of a Wal- Mart Supercenter by Inglewood voters has parallels with a similar development in Santa Monica nearly four years ago.
Target, a division of Dayton-Hudson, proposed to build a discount store on almost half of a city block at Fifth Street and Santa Monica Boulevard.
Both Target and Wal-Mart said their projects would be good for the community. Both chains are famous for quality merchandise and low prices. Both stores would have provided substantial economic benefit for their respective communities.
Inglewood’s Wal-Mart Supercenter would have employed up to 1,200 people. The Santa Monica Target would have employed 400 people. A limited number of employees of both chains are represented by bargaining units but the stores are generally regarded as non-union shops.
In Inglewood, the United Food and Commercial Workers Union and the Teamsters led the charge against Wal- Mart. The UFCW is the union that totally mishandled the disastrous five-month supermarket strike involving Ralph’s, Albertsons and Vons/Pavilions.
In Santa Monica, the retail clerks union, among others, opposed Target.
Local Democrats and other liberals followed suit. Affordable housing advocates, led by Santa Monica for Renters’ Rights co-chair, Denny Zane, opposed Target because the project contained no housing element.
Traffic was a big issue, too. There was no question that the store would generate traffic trips. But despite that some council members approved projects like the downtown Transit Mall and parking meters on Fourth Street, which create just as much traffic as Target would have, they still thought Target would be “too much.” Those who advocate no growth bemoaned further erosion of what they perceived as a “quiet, seaside community.”
Unlike Inglewood, where voters rejected Wal-Mart, here it was the City Council who killed the proposed Target. Since then, approval has been granted for four, massive, five-floor, market-rate, mixed use, apartment buildings on the site.
Concerns about traffic congestion and pollution that a large commercial development brings to neighborhoods are valid. But there also are many benefits that accrue to a community.
Inglewood voters said no to desperately needed local jobs, $5 million in tax revenue and a mall where the 87 percent of Inglewood shoppers who now shop out of town could shop locally.
Santa Monica also lost local shopping and employment, millions in tax income, and hundreds of thousands of dollars in support for local arts, schools and charities.
What confounds me is that the same old crowd that cries for jobs, equal rights, social justice, clean and safe working environments, fair wages and full employment almost always opposes these projects.
Labor unions fight them strictly because they involve non-union retailers. In other words, “If we don’t represent employees, nobody works.” Forget noble causes. The shortsighted union movement today is about protecting only its members, and maintaining big union boss’ salaries and perks. If you don’t believe me, ask any grocery clerk.
Even the Los Angeles Alliance for a New Economy donated to and supported the anti-Wal-Mart effort. LAANE has been and still is behind the “living wage” movement here and is a strong political ally to pro-union SMRR and Santa Monicans Allied for Responsible Tourism.
Hired gun, the Rev. Jesse Jackson, jetted into town and was carted by limousine from press opportunity to press opportunity, crusading against Wal-Mart, the creation of jobs and the value priced shopping so vital to the survival of those in minority neighborhoods on limited or no incomes. These days, Jackson isn’t a civil rights leader. It seems that he’s a mouthpiece for the highest bidder.
In communities like Inglewood, you’d think anything that provides employment and income to those with limited education, experience or training would get enthusiastic support, and that a stepping stone to higher wages and a career would be well received. But, like others, 35th District Congresswoman Maxine Waters also fought Wal-Mart tooth and nail. I guess they would all rather have grinding poverty, welfare, unemployment and crime.
With our local elections approaching, you can bet various labor unions will once again co-opt SMRR and its cronies with money and campaign workers — in exchange for pushing their pro-union agenda. But don’t let them fool you.
While they’ll talk workers’ rights, living wages and social justice, they really mean only union members have the right to work here, union bosses deserve “living high” wages and social justice is a business with a union contract.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 9, 2004. Read the original PDF.