Skip to content

‘This sand is your sand, this sand is my sand …’

Published:

By Ron Scott Smith

“At one o’clock we will sell at public outcry to the highest bidder, the Pacific Ocean, draped with a western sky of scarlet and gold … we will sell a southern horizon, rimmed with a choice collection of purple mountains … the title to the land will be guaranteed to the owner. The title to the ocean and sunset, the hills and the clouds … and the song of birds is guaranteed by the beneficent God who bestowed them in all their beauty …”

Thus raved the loquacious auctioneer, Tom Fitch, only slightly carried away, as he prepared to sell off the first pieces of Santa Monica back in 1920-something.

They who bought weren't going to take the poetic pitchman literally were they?

They were. Apparently some guys up along this coastline really think the ocean and the sunsets and the birds are written into their home ownership titles.

David Geffen for one. The California Coastal Commission, overseers of the shorelines that belong to no one in particular, but everyone in general, recently ordered a path be opened next to Geffen’s seaside mansion that would allow the public to walk from the Pacific Coast Highway to the sand. Their sand. His sand, but their sand too. It’s the people’s sand on that nice little beach out there, not just yours, David, so lighten up, and open up. But no — he’s got the pathway blocked, the city of Malibu in his corner, and together they’re suing the Coastal Commission and the California Conservancy, along with an environmental group, Access For All, to keep us off “his” beach. I don’t know, are we that undesirable? That messy? Anybody else out there feeling a bit insecure and unworthy?

OK Dave, you had the ear, you found the talent, you got the hits and caught that big green wave which carried you right up onto those pristine sands outside your estate. Your Dream Works. But that does-n’t mean you own that wave or the sand it crashes on. Just be grateful you’ve been able to ride it, and enjoy the view of it from your windows. Look where it’s brought you! But if it pisses you off to have to look at, or join others out there enjoying that sun and that surf — people whose dreams work not quite so magnificently, then good advice might be to take some of your many millions and go somewhere a little more private and a little further away from the huddled masses on “your” beach. What limitless options to have at your disposal! What breathtaking choices available to you! And you choose to sue everybody in sight for trying to offer up the ocean to all, to pauper and record/movie mogul alike.

David Geffen discovered Don Henley and the Eagles, among others, to begin his lifelong ascent into that rarefied air — the financial stratosphere where men can own oceans. Don Henley once wrote this verse about the town he now lives in for a beautiful and haunting song called “The Last Resort.”

“Then the chilly winds blew down across the desert Through the canyons of the coast to the Malibu.

Where the pretty people play, hungry for power To light their neon way and give them things to do.”

So, it would seem, he had some idea of what he was getting into when his own wave landed him up in “the Malibu” too. But now, he fights that same damn bothersome Coastal Commission that his old buddy Geffen fights, because it has recently given its approval for a large commercial and residential development to be built near the civic center. It would no doubt mean increased traffic headaches, and that drive up PCH at the end of an afternoon of high lunch and business in town is already a bitch, even without this new development. And there’d surely be more visitors from poor-er places like LA and, uh, Santa Monica. Did I mention insecure and unworthy? The fact that this new center may include sports fields, day care facilities, and senior citizen/ teen centers, along with needed housing, it would seem to give it some kind of redemptive quality, but … no, the fight is on.

It’s odd and sad to see this music icon, one with songs of truly great social consciousness, engage in this battle to ostensibly give his life more privacy, more ease with which to be lived, and, as with Geffen, keep people away. You’ve got the house up there nestled into a hillside full of the endangered sage and chaparral but now that you do — no more houses, no more development, enough is enough — save the sage. Something like that, right?

In Poe’s classic “Masque Of The Red Death” — not soon to be re-released by Geffen’s Dreamworks — the upper crust, the wealthy denizens, gather inside and close their mega-castle in defiance to the pestilence and sickness sweeping through the lowly outside world. The lucky ones inside, however, soon are felled by the worse plague already within.

Don Henley’s words again: “Who will provide the grand design, what is yours and what is mine Cause there is no more new frontier, we have got to make it here.

We satisfy our endless needs and justify our bloody deeds In the name of destiny and in the name of God.” (Ron Scott Smith).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 18, 2002. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe