By John Thacker Regional vice president/managing director Loews Santa Monica Beach Hotel
In reference to the letter you printed from Rabbi Comess-Daniels, I would like to point out the following: For more than two years, the union has made repeated efforts to force the owners of Loews Santa Monica Beach Hotel to forfeit our employees’ right to decide on union representation. These efforts have included baseless unfair labor practice charges. The National Labor Relations Board has not found Loews Santa Monica Beach Hotel in violation of any of the charges. We have agreed to do “postings,” which expressly indicate no admission of guilt, as they don’t involve lengthy and expensive investigations and they simply state our position on various issues.
No workers have been unfairly targeted for disciplinary action … for any reason. With the exception of four or five vocal supporters, we have no idea who supports the living wage and who does not. It is a non-issue within the hotel. The letter you printed used “alleged” four times. For good reason. We are fair to all of our team members.
The latest effort by the Hotel Employees and Restaurant Employees Union (H.E.R.E.) to force unionization is their attempt to institute a “living wage” on select businesses in Santa Monica. The union’s dubious motives became clear when it was exposed that hotels with a collective bargaining agreement with Local 814 of H.E.R.E. are exempt from the new living wage ordinance. At Loews Santa Monica Beach Hotel, almost all of our non-tipped employees already make a wage equal to or better than the proposal. We also pay 91 percent of the health insurance for our employees, which comes out to more than the hourly differential outlined in the ordinance. Furthermore, we provide free meals, free parking and free life insurance, just to mention a few of Loews’ additional benefits. Perhaps those are some of the reasons why our employees believe they do not need or want union representation.
The newest issue with the living wage ordinance is the inclusion of tipped employees. From the outset of the local debate on a living wage, even the advocates recognized that most tipped employees currently make substantial incomes from tips. In fact, the economic study prepared for the city assumed that employees receiving at least one-half of their income from tips would be excluded. So when it became clear that without including tipped-employees, the law would have virtually no impact on the beach hotels that Local 814 is trying to organize, the proposal was modified. This is just one more piece of evidence of the union’s true agenda behind the wage ordinance.
Despite attempts to portray Loews Santa Monica Beach Hotel in a negative light, the truth remains: We are not anti-union. In fact, one third of Loews Hotels are already unionized. We are pro-employee and firmly believe that our employees, not the union, not management and not the community, should determine whether they want to join the union. From the beginning, we have agreed to have a secret ballot election, as provided for in law by the National Labor Relations Act. This would be the fairest and quickest way to resolve the dispute, but the union has refused to have an election. If employees vote for a union, the hotel would recognize the union. It is that simple.
Loews Santa Beach Hotel has been a good employer, a good neighbor and a strong corporate citizen. Our wages and benefits equal or exceed other local hotel properties and surpass those at unionized hotels in Santa Monica. Our efforts to promote diversity within employee and management ranks and to embrace the welfare-to-work initiative have been a model for the industry. Our commitment to the City of Santa Monica goes back over 14 years when we spurred the revitalization of the beach area.
People are, of course, free to continue to demonstrate in front of our hotel. Just be aware that the consequence is discouraging travelers and tourists from visiting Santa Monica, thereby hurting the very people Santa Monicans Allied for Responsible Tourism purports to be fighting for. I have offered to meet one-on-one with Rabbi Comess-Daniels if he is willing to hear the other side of the story.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on September 7, 2002. Read the original PDF.