By Victor Fresco Santa Monica
Tom Larmore compares his “developer’s right to demolish” initiative (Measure A) to a woman’s right to choose to terminate her pregnancy. (Daily Press, 1/22/03).
Mr. Larmore seems to be saying that since women should have sole control over decisions affecting their bodies, developers should have sole control over decisions affecting a neighborhood. Nonsense.
Proposition A would make compliance with Santa Monica’s Landmark Ordinance optional. Mr. Larmore likes to talk about giving homeowners the freedom to choose the fate of their property. What he doesn’t mention is that most home demolitions are done by developers building spec homes. Are developers homeowners? They certainly own the home they’re about to demolish. But are they homeowners that live in and care about the community? Do they care about how the destruction of a historically and architecturally significant structure may impact the character and value of a neighborhood? Yet if Proposition A passes, these “homeowners” would have sole authority to determine whether an existing home has historical significance and should be saved.
Most older homes are NOT worthy of preservation and very few are given landmark status. In the 26 years that Santa Monica has had its historic preservation ordinance, ONLY 16 HOMES HAVE BEEN LANDMARKED IN THE ENTIRE CITY. That’s less than one home per year, out of 6,500 single family residences!
Last year, 96 of 97 permits for demolition were approved. All one has to do is look around his own neighborhood and ask: Are too many homes currently being saved?
Clearly, there has not been an epidemic of landmarking under the current ordinance. For most Santa Monicans, Proposition A is a solution in search of a problem. But for developers, its passage would be a huge gift, eliminating one of the few tools a neighborhood has to protect its existing character.
Santa Monicans must not lose their right to participate in decisions affecting their neighborhoods. Vote “NO” on Proposition A.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on January 27, 2003. Read the original PDF.