By Sheila Kuehl
(Editor’s note: This the fifth article in a series written by state Sen. Sheila Kuehl (D-Santa Monica) focusing on the state budget. Today, she addresses the worker’s comp legislation that passed under threat of the initiative and the problems that will still face workers and employers).
For both workers and their bosses, deciphering what’s covered under the new workman’s compensation law can be daunting.
Under the current law, an injured employee may switch to his or her own doctor after 30 days. Under the new law, employers, beginning in 2005, are authorized to create and use a network of doctors for their injured workers. “Standards” for these networks are to be set by the worker’s comp administrative director and must include a sufficient number of physicians and adequate access. It also requires disclosure of so-called economic profiling policies, under which employers can toss a doctor out of the network for spending too much on their patients. Injured employees can go from one doctor to another up to three times. They can then can ask for an independent review if they are still not happy.
But there are problems with this. There are no real standards for those health care providers who will be chosen for the networks and no standards for how the networks will be required to deal with their patients. Though standards were suggested throughout the negotiations with Governor Schwarzenegger, the final bill had none — not even as much as HMOs now have. There’s no quality assurance process, no real review of the networks by the Department of Worker’s Comp. There’s no requirement that the network provide any patient assistance and no requirement that there be a grievance procedure — you can go to another doctor, that’s it. The network can’t be disapproved by the administrator just based on which doctors are in it. The composition of the network is entirely up to the employer or the insurance company. And, there’s no real separation of medical and fiscal decision-making, such as what we’ve tried to ensure in other medical groups.
A worker who has gone through three doctors in the network may request an independent medical review. The person who asks for the review, whether it’s the worker or the employer, may request a face-to-face meeting with the reviewer. This is a cost driver, not a cost saver. And, it’s not the way it’s done in any of our group health plans, which provide more efficient medical reviews. Interestingly, the employer who was consulted by the administration about how to set this up recommended this construct because they said, “It’s the way Florida does it, and they save money.” But it’s not the way Florida does it. All the quality and patient protection standards (fines, revoking licenses, audits, complaints) used in Florida were left out of this bill concerning networks.
When temporary disability payments, which may not exceed 104 weeks in the first two years except for a few disabilities, run out the employer must begin paying a reasonable estimate of permanent disability, if it hasn’t been set yet. This is a good thing. Also, an employer is rewarded for offering alternative work to an injured worker.
However, as in the now-defunct initiative, only objective standards will be used to judge permanent disability — subjective issues such as pain will not, for the most part, be taken into account.
Like the initiative, injury will be “apportioned” in terms of causation. Workers will be required to reveal their prior medical history so any work injury can be attributed to all its causes and worker’s comp will only compensate that percentage caused by the work injury. Think about your knees in contemplating this.
A good provision in the law is immediate medical care so that injured workers are treated sooner.
The savings are not passed back to employers in this legislation. Although the governor said this was the primary reason for pushing this strong reform, he refused to put any rate regulation in it. Instead, the administrative director is to contract with a “qualified organization” to study (yes, study) the worker’s comp insurance market and the effect of both the 2003 and 2004 reform legislation on premium rates.
The report is due Jan. 1, 2006. If it’s not saving employers money, they may submit proposals to the Legislature for regulating insurance rates.
This is modestly better than the initiative but worse for injured workers than current law. The jury is still way out on whether employers will realize any savings or whether insurers, as they did this year, will simply claim the identified savings did not come to pass. The governor’s reason for emphasizing this issue in such an aggressive way was to reduce worker’s comp premiums to businesses. Let’s make sure he knows if it’s working or not.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 17, 2004. Read the original PDF.