By John Logan Teacher, Industrial Relations Department at the London School of Economics
If you’re still undecided about how to vote on the election’s most contentious proposition — Prop. 75, which would restrict the ability of public-employee unions to use dues money for political campaigns — here are 10 points in favor of a “no” vote. 10. It’s leading proponent, right-wing political operative Lew Uhler, is a former activist of the extremist John Birch Society. 9. Prop. 75 supporters are motivated by ideology, not fairness. They include antitax crusader Howard Ahmanson, who believes that the Bible opposes the minimum wage, and the anti-union National Right to Work Committee. 8. It unjustly singles out public sector unions. If Prop. 75 were really necessary to protect the rights of ordinary employees, as its proponents claim, it should apply to private-sector unions as well. 7. Prop. 75 is unnecessary. Union members already have the right to stipulate that their dues money should not be used for political purposes. Its true purpose is to weaken unions by tying them up in red tape. 6. It would further distort the financial imbalance in California politics. According to the non-partisan Center for Responsive Politics, corporations already outspend unions by a margin of 24-1. Prop. 75 would make this situation even worse by silencing the voice of ordinary employees without placing any restrictions on the political contributions of corporations. 5. Voters, legislators and judges in several other states have rejected similar measures as bad public policy. Earlier this year, so-called “paycheck protection” measures were rejected by a Republican judge in Ohio — who ruled that it violated unions’ constitutional right to free speech — and state legislators in Georgia. 4. This is not the first time that “paycheck protection” has been considered in California. Voters rejected a similar measure, Prop. 226, in 1998. Union members voted overwhelmingly against it. Many of the same anti-union activists who promoted Prop. 226 are behind Prop. 75. 3. A handful of ultra-wealthy individuals, large corporations, investment bankers and longtime adversaries of unions have bankrolled virtually the entire Prop. 75 campaign — hardly the grassroots movement of ordinary employees, concerned citizens and small businesses that its backers would have you believe. 2. The people who are the alleged beneficiaries of the measure, public sector workers, overwhelmingly oppose it. Only 181 of the 1 million union members who would be affected by Prop. 75 have come out in support of it. Supporters of Prop. 75 were so short of genuine pubic sector employees who support the measure that they had to purchase a stock photograph of a firefighter from Seattle-based Getty Images for their brochures. 1. Governor Schwarzenegger thinks that Prop. 75 is a good idea. Indeed, his advisors were the very people who persuaded Lew Uhler to start his campaign against public sector unions in the first place. What else do you need to know?
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on November 5, 2005. Read the original PDF.