Skip to content

Trading the simple life for a chance to have it all

Published:

By Caroline Bodkin

It’s a simple concept that’s hard to understand: When you make one choice, you forego other options.

When you select ASU, you forego UCLA. When you propose to Barbara, you let go of long lost Lucy.

When my friend Ian decided to get married, his theoretical life as a poet living on a whim in South America was forsaken in the interest of his wife and stability for the family they’ll make.

Once a potential, it is now a “could’ve been.”

When my friend Megan decided to join her boyfriend, an up-and-coming musician, in Los Angeles, she knew she would have to leave the non-profit job she loves and the state she’s getting cozy in. But she knew he could only pursue his dream in that place, and so moving seemed the right thing to do and she was gracious about it.

Graciously is the only way to do such a thing. Because while giving things up is hard, giving things up without actually letting them go is even harder — you end up resenting the person, place or thing you gave them up for. And that resentment or nostalgia takes up so much space inside you, there’s no room to enjoy the thing you chose to do.

We make choices. We have to because we can’t do everything.

There must have been a “simpler” time and “simpler” places where options were limited and choices were rare. Take pioneers in the 1800s. You grow up in your home, go to your one-room schoolhouse until you’re old enough to work with your family on the farm, then marry the boy down the street and raise kids who do the same thing.

Those people didn’t have MTV, they didn’t know they could apply to be on “Road Rules” or aspire to become the next Britney Spears, so they didn’t care that they’d never do it.

They didn’t watch “Extreme Makeover: Home Edition” and then turn to their spouse and say, “Why doesn’t our home look like that?” They loved the boy down the street because the two of them were unselfish about the life they wanted to live. There was no me, me, me. There was no, “Baby, I know you and I need to take care of the farm, but I’m feeling stuck and I need to go find my inner child vis a vis New York City.”

There was reality. Their choices were few, but you can’t tell me these people weren’t happy. Or, at least, you can’t tell me they were unhappy because their lives were simple, their choices limited. They took care of the basics first: Eat, sleep, survive, fall in love, make babies and help the babies survive. And if they had time, they wrote a novel or figured out how to improve the plow. That’s it.

And you know what? They did great things.

We don’t read about “lack of fulfillment” in their novels.

I know my friend Megan well. I know that she, in her heart, wants simple things — the modern day pioneer life. She does-n’t care about the fancy house or the chance to be on “Road Rules.” She is a happy person. Her priorities, in my mind, are noble: survival, family, friends, love.

I heard that she’s no longer moving to be with her boyfriend because they realized their lives are going in different directions. She’d move to be with him, but he’d be on the road with his band all but 15 days out of the year. Not much of a shared life in that.

I haven’t spoken to her about it, so I don’t know the details, but I know they love each other.

I know this must be awful. And I wonder if he’s aware of the choice he’s making. I have this personal, sad feeling that he’s not, and that someday he’ll regret it.

A great saying is “Better is the enemy of good.” I believe this is true. Opportunity cost is a killer. But what’s wrong with making a choice? What’s wrong with knowing yourself well enough to say this thing is right for me, and I don’t need the rest of it?

The person who wants to have it all, in my mind, truly has very little.

I wish all the best and all the love in the world to my friend Megan. I wish her tomato plants and family dinners. Not because this is the right choice, but because it’s her choice.

And because she’s willing to give up the rest of it. (Caroline Bodkin lives in Los Angeles and wonders daily if she’ll miss her calling. You can ).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 3, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe