By Barbara Inatsugu former president League of Women Voters of Santa Monica
Editor: For years, the League of Women Voters has worked to inform voters. For years, League members have registered citizens to vote and have worked even harder to inspire them to vote on Election Day. On November 5, Santa Monica voters will be voting on issues of fundamental importance to our community — of fundamental importance to good government in Santa Monica. One of these ballot measures, HH, is, in reality, multiple measures rolled into one. As a voter, you should read it carefully — if you don’t agree with all its provisions, VOTE NO on HH.
If you agree with only one of its many provisions, you should VOTE NO on HH. As Herb Katz noted during the Santa Monica Chamber of Commerce debate on October 16, there are a number of charter amendments in the measure, each one of which qualifies to be a separate ballot measure. The good government thing to do is to VOTE NO on HH.
In recent weeks there have been several letters to the editor dealing with various parts of Measure HH (VERITAS). I will focus the rest of my comments on the issue of establishing a primary election in March of each election year.
Supporters of HH say that the VERITAS system of elections will cost less — will reduce the amount of money in political races. But they propose a system that will cost the city more and will result in holding two elections, rather than one, every two years — a primary and a general. That means it will cost Santa Monica residents more.
Supporters propose a system of elections that would require many, if not most, candidates to compete in two elections (primary and general). That would mean planning materials for print and distribution over two elections, rather than one.
Supporters of HH also propose a system that would lengthen the time period of campaigns. Rather than pulling papers in July, three to four months before an election, candidates would be pulling papers nine to ten months before the election. Accordingly, timelines for fundraising and campaigning would begin significantly earlier to accommodate the spring primary and really not stop until election day in early November.
What was it they said about needing less money and resources?! The League believes that winning candidates should optimally receive at least 50 percent of the votes cast. Rather than establish a costly primary, however, perhaps it would make more sense to look at other approaches to conducting elections that accomplish the same thing in one election. Perhaps a Community Voices-type of input, combined with study sessions, would be appropriate before bringing this kind of question to the voters of Santa Monica.
Measure HH would create lame ducks and ducks in waiting. Currently, the city budget is discussed, debated and settled before the first candidate pulls papers. Under the VERITAS system, an incumbent who chooses not to run again, or who is defeated in the primary, would be a lame-duck voice during most of the budget process/debates.
A non-incumbent who won outright in the primary (before budget adoption) would not assume office until December and would have no official voice in the budget process.
And then there is the issue of voter turnout, which is usually much less in a primary election. This could aggravate the current situation in which a candidate could be elected outright with more than 50 percent of the votes cast, even though the total number of votes cast were significantly less than half of the total number of registered, eligible voters. Establishing a primary does not resolve issues related to voter turnout or voter empowerment, regardless of whether votes are cast by district or at-large.
When I first moved to Santa Monica, local elections were held in April. Turnout was so abysmal that, as a community, we decided to move our elections to coincide with the state-wide general election in November, when there is a demonstrably higher rate of voter turnout. The move in dates was neither frivolous nor an accident! It was intended to get more people actively involved in local government.
Supporters and opponents of HH both talk the language of good government, of inclusion, of empowerment, of voice. There is no good or evil in this contest. There is, however, clear disagreement over what makes good government and what promotes the kind of good decision-making that reflects the will of the people of Santa Monica.
This is your government and your vote. The issues in this election are fundamental and effect us all. Before you vote, study the issues, look at the larger picture. Don't be fooled by rhetoric.
Remember, vote on Nov. 5 and VOTE NO on HH.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 28, 2002. Read the original PDF.