Skip to content

War in Iraq, a progress report on a work in progress

Published:

By Ed Silverstein

If you had been listening to Iraq’s minister of information, Mohammed Said Sahaf, you would have known the coalition troops were trapped in Basrah, Um Qaser and Baghdad, and their bellies would soon be grilling in hell. To paraphrase Mark Twain: “Reports of the coalition’s demise were greatly exaggerated.”

At this writing, the war in Iraq is all but won. It has been carried out with a minimal loss of life and infrastructure. American and British casualties were few. The number of Iraqi civilian deaths was remarkably low in light of the extent of bombing in Baghdad and other cities. And although the number of Iraqi soldiers killed is unknown, total Iraqi-war related deaths will not even begin to approach the dire 500,000 predicted by the UN. It is even possible that more Iraqis would have been killed had Hussein remained in power through the completion of inspections.

Even if this war did nothing more than get the Iraqi people out from under a brutal regime whose idea of family values was using their wives and children as human shields, then my support was justified. But as I had previously opined, our show of strength has induced other benefits.

The swift fall of Baghdad probably resulted in North Korea’s capitulation on having multi-national talks on nuclear oversight. Iran has also suggested that it might allow inspections of its own nuclear facilities. Even Saudi Arabia has begun to make noises about a shift toward a more responsive form of government. And Syria, under pressure from the U.S., has closed its borders to the fleeing Iraqi war criminals. They may even be forced to reconsider their support of terrorist groups such as Hezbollah, Hamas and Islamic Jihad. If this occurs, along with the elimination of Saddam’s cash for suicide bombings program, it would be a blow to terrorism and would remove a major impediment to the Israeli/Palestinian peace process.

There is, of course, the potential for Islamic moderates to embrace religious extremism. This could increase anti- Americanism, as well as terrorism. One way to diffuse this prospect is for President Bush to heed Colin Powell’s advice and opt for a strong U.N. involvement. Bush also should allow a broad multi-national participation in the reconstruction process — with one exception.

France led the charge to castigate the United States for its failure to abide by the U.N. Security Council, yet, by selling banned weapons and systems to Hussein, they systematically defied mandated sanctions from that very same body. The French also negotiated secret oil deals, purportedly worth as much as $60 billion, that likely led to their pre-announcement of their intent to veto any war resolution. And, while I don’t advocate boycotting French and restaurants here which mainly hurts their American employees, I remain opposed to France profiting from U.S. funded reconstruction. Instead I suggest Bush send Chirac a copy of “The Little Red Hen.”

That is not to say that the jingoistic policies of the Bush administration are any better.

The President’s motivations remain highly suspect as is evidenced by his ever-shifting rationale for going to war. First it was retribution for 9/11. When no link between Al Qaeda and Saddam Hussein could be established, Bush shifted gears and blamed programs for nuclear and other weapons of mass destruction. Unfortunately the evidence of a nuclear program turned out to be crude forgeries.

That this administration, with its vast resources, gave these forgeries credibility, defies any reasonable explanation. And when attacking troops were unable, to date, to find any concrete evidence of the supposedly vast stocks of chemical and biological weapons, they suddenly no longer mattered.

The war was a humanitarian intervention waged solely to liberate the people of Iraq from a brutal regime.

Whatever the truth is one thing we know for certain. The first mission of war was to protect the oil. And well before the blood had dried on the battlefield, the first contract had already been awarded to one of President Bush’s major contributors, Halliburton.

This $7 billion dollar gift was completed with out any bidding and under a cloak of secrecy designed to defeat all reasonable oversight and criticism.

We can only hope that the President feels a greater sense of responsibility to the people he just “liberated” than he has demonstrated to those who voted for him. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer living in Santa Monica. Comments and billion dollar defense contracts can be e-mailed to:)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 17, 2003. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe