Skip to content

War on terror abuses victims around world

Published:

By Beth Solomon

WASHINGTON — The vicious regime of Saddam Hussein sent its opponents to a prison called Abu Ghraib, 20 miles west of Baghdad, where they were tortured, beaten and abused in barbaric cells.

When U.S. troops arrived to liberate the Iraqi people, they closed the prison. Then they renovated it. Then they began torturing Iraqi citizens again.

This week, six U.S. military police were charged with torture and other abuse of Iraqi citizens at Abu Ghraib. According to military charges, U.S. service men and women forced prisoners to lie in “a pyramid of naked detainees” and jumped on their prone bodies. Detainees were ordered to strip and perform or simulate sex acts. A hooded man allegedly was made to stand on a box of meals ready to eat and was told that he would be electrocuted if he fell off. A soldier unzipped a body bag and took snapshots of a detainee’s frozen corpse inside. Several times, soldiers were photographed and videotaped posing in front of humiliated inmates. One gave a thumbs-up sign in front of the human pyramid.

These are just the first stories to emerge in a burgeoning investigation of American torture of Iraqi soldiers and civilians. Photographs and video of alleged torture and sexual abuse of Iraqi women and children have not yet been released.

The story, broken by CBS’s 60 Minutes II and the New Yorker’s Seymour Hersh, is making headlines in the United States. It’s the main story — the only story — on Arab and Muslim TV networks around the globe.

It’s horrifying to think that U.S. service men and women — in significant numbers — have been perpetrating unspeakable crimes under the authority of our government.

But in another hot, sandy area — just a few miles away from Santa Monica in Pomona, Calif. — a parallel story is emerging.

An affidavit released this week reveals how FBI counterterrorism officials badly misused the laws of the United States to wrongly incriminate a dozen young environmentalists and subject them to harassment, fear and damage to their reputations.

With no evidence, but plenty of suspicion about “eco-terrorists,” FBI officials wove a tissue of disparate facts together to falsely implicate a young solar-panel installer, Josh Connole, in the 2003 firebombings of 72 Hummers near San Bernandino.

The FBI considered Connole a suspect because “individuals who commit illegal actions in the name of the Earth Liberation Front movement, (sic) are generally tied to aboveground (sic) groups that promote environmental, social and political goals similar to the those of the ELF.”

Connole’s crime was organizing a weekly peace vigil in his hometown of Brea in conservative Orange County.

The FBI put that information together with an anonymous tip from a Pomona resident warning that Connole and his housemates had pro-environment stickers on their cars. Even more suspiciously, the environmental cooperative owned electric cars that also carried pro-environmental bumper stickers. And one of Connole’s housemates — along with his father — had criticized excessive use of fossil fuels on a Web site.

FBI officials took this “evidence” and concocted a narrative in which Connole was the chief antagonist — I mean eco-terrorist. Back in Washington at FBI headquarters, officials compared images of Connole and silhouettes from the Hummer fire surveillance videos. They concluded that both images depicted tall, lanky men with brown hair.

Finally, an FBI canine was able to trace the scent of Connole back to his house after he walked the same route from a nearby convenience store.

The FBI hauled Connole into jail and threatened him with life in prison if he didn’t confess to the crime.

In an eerie foreshadowing of prison incidents 10,000 miles away, counterter-rorism officials kept Connole in a metal cell with the lights on all day and all night. They served food that, as a vegetarian, he could not eat.

The degree of the FBI’s humiliation, abuse and misuse of power pales in comparison to the latest reports coming out of Iraq, but the common elements warrant close attention.

While U.S. government officials — whether in Pomona or Iraq — are under pressure, operating in an environment with real threats, the government’s ability to misconstrue facts, manufacture nonexistent connections and inflict devastating abuse on innocent people is more frightening than any exterior threat facing our country.

A much bigger threat is the destruction of the credibility of the U.S. government and the frontal attack on our democracy by our own officials. Forget about selling democracy abroad — I’m talking about re-learning how to it at home.

Our democracy works because we have been able to hold our government accountable. In Pomona and Iraq, the U.S. government clearly is not.

On public radio, Seymour Hersh could have been talking about Pomona when he said the following about U.S. military torturers in Iraq: “It comes back to this town, to this government, to a bunch of people who thought they were going to smoke ’em out.” (Beth Solomon is a Left Coast writer reachable at).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 5, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe