Skip to content

Wasn’t Sen. Edwards the obvious choice?

Published:

By THING BY LARA M. BROWN, PH.D

On July 6, Democratic nominee John Kerry announced that Sen. John Edwards would be his running mate, to the delight of many in the Democratic Party. According to several media reports last week, Edwards was the right choice, even if according to the Bush campaign he was Kerry’s second choice.

Why did it take Kerry so long — more than four months — to do the right thing? He wrapped up the nomination on Super Tuesday, March 2, the day California voted and the day word leaked out that Edwards, Kerry’s last serious competition, would withdraw from the race.

Kerry took more time to choose his running mate than the voters took to choose him as the Democratic Nominee. Much more.

While some voters, especially those in Iowa and New Hampshire, have nearly an entire year to get to know the candidates running for their political party’s presidential nomination, most voters in most states are fortunate if they have two or three weeks to assess the candidates.

And voters never have the benefit of professional investigators or a committee to help them vet the credentials of those running. Voters have to rely on the available media reports and the materials (advertisements and position papers) produced by the campaigns. They have to rely on their own judgments, assessing a candidate’s likeability and electability. They have to try to anticipate how well a candidate’s message will play against another message, in what states, and to whom.

In most elections, voters are asked to do something that candidates are never asked to do — make a rational decision with incomplete information and make that decision in a short period of time. Even when incumbents aren’t sure of what they’re voting on in Congress, they can be assured that someone in his or her political party has done the research and that his or her vote is not an “irrational” one, given where he or she stands on the issues. Voters never have such assurances.

In this past primary, most voters had less than a week to meet, see, review, and decide, which candidate they would cast their ballot for.

But if we, the voters, effectively decided that he, Kerry, should be the presidential nominee in less than eight weeks (the Iowa caucuses were held on Jan. 19), then why did it take Kerry four months to decide who should join him as his running mate?

Some would defend Kerry, saying that he had to take into account things like the background of the candidates, and whether or not his running mate would help him, hurt him, bring him votes in various regions, balance the ticket, appeal to certain constituencies, etc. Some would say that this was Kerry’s first opportunity to appear presidential — that it was important that he not rush to judgment, that he appear to be making his own choice, and that they are glad that he took his time.

I would argue that they’re wrong. Kerry is a politician who simply needed to make a political decision.

HERE’S THE THING: Since March, the Kerry campaign and the 527 organizations supporting his candidacy have significantly outspent President Bush’s campaign on television advertising. For Kerry to still be even with Bush or behind in some of the key swing state polls says that Kerry needed to do more during these past few months to convince voters that he could be President of the United States. Whether or not naming his running mate early would have helped Kerry is uncertain, but by not having done it, Kerry squandered a leadership opportunity that was his for the taking.

Kerry left himself open to attack with no “wingman” to defend him on the campaign trail, and far from looking deliberative he reinforced the perception that he was flip-flopping with all of the emphasis on the “veepstakes” guessing-games. Would he name McCain, Gephardt, Vilsack, Clark, Edwards, or perhaps, even Biden or Bayh? Why couldn’t he make up his mind?

Presidents need to make decisions quickly. They’re only in office four years. Most need to pick their entire cabinet in four months.

If Kerry had named Edwards by the first week of May, he would not only have sent a message to the Democratic base that he trusted them and their judgment (Edwards came in second in several of the primaries), but he also would have had another two months to broaden the appeal of the ticket to the swing voters in the swing states.

What was the use of frontloading the primaries if Kerry wasn’t planning on using the time to promote the Democratic ticket? (Lara M. Brown, Ph.D., is a visiting scholar at UCLA’s Institute for Social Science Research and she served on Sen. John Edwards National Finance Council for his presidential campaign. She).

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 15, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe