By Babak Samareh
I am sure I am not alone in finding the article by M.S. Berliner Ph.D. somewhat one-sided (SMDP, April 19, page 4). It is hard to believe that such reductionalist attitudes still exists in the face of the advancements that science has made — particularly in the area of theoretical physics and ecology. Scientific reductionism has allowed us to separate ourselves from our environment and helped us to better understand the workings of the world around us.
However, any serious scientist is aware that a sustainable system is one that can regulate itself and maintain a state of homeostasis. Homeostasis or internal control requires that no single parameter within the system dominate or take control of the entire system. For example, if in a given system one organism, say a rabbit, were to multiply without any checks and balances, it would place an unsustainable stress on the entire system. As the rabbits multiply, the food supply and habitat diminish and the cycle leads to the mass destruction of the rabbits.
Now scientific advancements have afforded us the ability to counter many of these limitations by artificially increasing food supplies through agriculture, decreasing death rates though medical intervention and so on. But what these advancements fail to consider is that in a system that is finite, continuous growth and expansion is a fallacy.
The reason that we now find ourselves in this environmental predicament is in no small way related to the uncontrolled use of the advancements we have made in the area of science. We are able to feed millions more but we don’t stop to consider whether this growth is sustainable, meaning that the 2 billion extra human beings that can now be supported place severe ecological, political and economical stress on the entire system — endangering the balance of the whole planet.
The days of looking at the world exclusively through the eyes of Sir Isaac Newton have come to an end.
Though his works were of incalculable value in bringing us to where we are, we must now embrace the finding of the new world of subatomic physics, which has shown us that there are no building blocks of nature and no isolated parts from which the world is assembled. There are only patterns of probability and that the entire system is one inseparable whole, which cannot fundamentally be divided.
We find ourselves in a vicarious situation in the beginning of the 21st Century and that is that we have outgrown the tools we have been using to view the world around us. We have out grown the billiard ball cause and effect scientific model and we must now embrace the systemic paradigm. As unpopular as the idea of the Earth revolving around the sun was to the medieval mind so it is today the idea that man is not above or superior to the environment but merely a fragment of it.We must strive to overcome this arrogant scientific illusion if we are to survive at all.
We must recognize that though our scientific zeal has been the source of the accumulation of tremendous knowledge, without the wisdom to use this knowledge we are placing not only ourselves but also the entire planet at risk. Man has a duty and that is to protect and maintain the fragile balance of nature.
What we need now is not more emphasis on science and technology but a shift in the way we perceive ourselves and our world — a shift in consciousness if you will. We must realize that we are not strangers in this world isolated and alone but integral parts of a fantastically complex web. This shift will at once empower us and make us aware of our responsibility to the entire system.
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on April 23, 2004. Read the original PDF.