Skip to content

We need to follow Florida’s lead on sex offenders

Published:

By COMMON SCENTS BY CAROLE ORLIN

Have you noticed how the state of Florida has received a disproportionate share of media coverage dating back to the “hanging chads” fiasco of the 2000 Bush/Gore battle?

My focus today is not on the hurricane disasters or the debate that surrounded the Terri Schiavo case earlier this year. Like most Americans, I have been closely watching the news about repeated abductions and murders of children in Florida. We all know about the indescribably tragic deaths of Sarah Lunde, Carly Brucia and Jessica Lunsford within the last 14 months. Florida’s beleaguered social-service system has also received national attention with the 2002 disappearance of little Rilya Wilson from a foster care home for 16 months before social services realized it. I am not sure that other states’ social-welfare and legal systems are not just as vulnerable to these tragedies as Florida’s. However, if Florida has to be the scapegoat, so be it, if it serves the purpose of forcing each state to review its own social-service systems and sexual-offender laws.

On May 2, 2005, in response to the Jessica Lunsford tragedy, Florida approved and Gov. Bush signed into law new legislation called the Jessica Lunsford’s Law, which mandates a 25-year to life sentence for certain sex offenders and thereafter monitoring them for life with a GPS tracking system. Even the ACLU, which often opposes governmental interference with civil liberties, supports this technology as an alternative to incarceration.

I was glad to see the mandatory 25-year sentence legislation and the GPS, but I could not help but think of Megan Nicole Kanka, after whom Megan’s Law is named. Megan was 7 years old in 1994, when she was lured into a neighbor’s home to see a new puppy. She was murdered there. Eighty-nine days later, New Jersey Gov. Christine Todd Whitman signed the first version of Megan’s Law, which subsequently became a federal law in 1996. In this instance a GPS would have been useless, as the predator was home where he was supposed to be. Nobody really thinks a monitoring device alone is enough to keep our children safe from these predators, but it is an important adjunct.

The Megan’s Law Web site, www.meganslaw.ca.gov (started in Sept. 2004), allows the public for the first time to access information about sex offenders from home computers. The California Megan’s Law makes it much easier to get important information such as the names, addresses, photos, sexual crimes (many of these offenders have committed other crimes, but they are not listed on this Web site) and identifying marks of the offenders from our home computers. But, be aware that under state laws, some registered sex offenders are not subject to public disclosure and are not listed on the Web site. Also, some offenders whose names are on the Web site, for some reason, do not have to have their photos or addresses listed. There are 380,000 registered sex offenders in the United States, although thousands of them have disappeared and the police do not know their whereabouts. Our state has 63,000 registered sex offenders. There are, at this writing, 47 registered sex offenders in Santa Monica; last week there were 46, so I guess we have recently welcomed another predator to Santa Monica.

A recent column in the Westside Apartment Monthly by Carl Lambert, Esq., addressed some serious issues with the Megan’s Law Disclosure Act. He states, for example, that although the legislature has allowed us to find out where these predators are, it does not allow landlords to deal with this potential problem. He emphasizes that privacy laws prevent landlords from warning tenants if a sex offender is living in their building. Under Megan’s Law, they are not allowed to discriminate against sex offenders or evict them. Yet, landlords are mandated to protect their clients from known risks. How’s that for a Catch-22? Lambert gave a powerful example of a case in Sacramento where a convicted rapist was found to be living in an apartment building that housed many college co-eds. The landlord could not evict the rapist and was faced with many people wanting out of their leases once they found out about the rapist. He goes on to point out that this particular issue was resolved when a group of people showed up at the rapist’s door carrying machine guns. If a landlord asks on a rental application if a person has been convicted of a sex crime, then does not allow him to live in the building, he risks being sued for discrimination. Lambert reported that the California Apartment Association is trying to solve this problem through legislation to give landlords the power to protect their other tenants. I’m sure this will be a long, tough battle. However, keeping in mind the extremely high recidivism rate of offenders, and the fact that by the time an offender is caught he has offended on the average of 117 times, it seems the landlord should be empowered to ensure his tenant’s safety as much as possible. Lambert also highlighted an important point: Not all offenders are the same. He gave the example of man who was convicted of indecent exposure for urinating in public. He is obviously not as dangerous as a rapist, but he does need etiquette training!

While researching this column, I perused the Megan’s Law Web site and found, to my shock, two very familiar faces. One is a man that works at a little place my husband and I go to every Sunday morning. The other lives just a few blocks away from us. Neither person seems threatening in any way. Also shocking were the addresses of other offenders that I did not recognize. So many live so close. I checked Venice, and there were 28 registered offenders; Brentwood has 26; Culver City 38; Beverly Hills 12; Malibu 2; Marina Del Rey 10; Mar Vista 3; etc. This is important information, and I think everyone should check the Web site. It also offers other information, including an FAQ section, facts about sex offenders, information on how to protect your family, etc.

Although there are definite problems with the Megan’s Law Disclosure Act, it is a major step for disseminating information that enables us to protect our children. That is one important step. Another is to take a close look at Florida’s new tough stance on sexual offenders and make sure our state and others soon follow suit. There is no time to waste. (Carole)

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on May 9, 2005. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe