By Ed Silverstein
Even as the search for weapons of mass destruction (WMD) in Iraq continues, a more serious issue has eclipsed their discovery. Were the American people, members of Congress, the United Nations and the rest of the world deliberately misled by the Bush administration?
In the days leading up to the war, President Bush, Vice President Cheney, Defense Secretary Rumsfeld, Secretary of State Colin Powell and a host of lesser Bushies informed the world that they had conclusive proof that Saddam Hussein possessed weapons of mass destruction.
More significant were their assertions that these weapons represented an imminent threat to our country and the world. We have since learned that not only was-n’t there conclusive proof of any looming threat, but the President and his minions may well have concealed evidence that some, if not all, of these weapons didn’t exist at all.
Never disclosed was a report from the Pentagon Intelligence Agency warning that there was no proof that Iraq possessed any WMDs. Far more damning was the administration’s use of a crudely forged document to suggest Iraq had a nuclear program and was trying to purchase uranium from Africa. The Bush administration would have us believe that the vast intelligence resources at their disposal were was so grossly incompetent as to be taken in by a document that was instantly discredited by the Blix team.
Even if we were to accept that the administration believed the document to be authentic, the White House — according to a senior CIA official — had been informed that an investigation in Africa had uncovered no substantiation of the document’s claims. And the administration’s attempt to show a link between Saddam Hussein and Al Qaeda was such hyperbole that it was dismissed out of hand by nearly the entire world, with the exception of about 60 percent of Americans. But as P.T. Barnum once said: “You’ll never go poor underestimating the intelligence of the American public.”
What is so troubling is that this administration was willing to exaggerate, obfuscate or fabricate in order to precipitate a war. Thousands of men, women and children died in that war including hundreds of our own soldiers. And if a President is willing to use deception in a matter of such grave consequence, what else is he willing to deceive us about?
Missile defense is a perfect example. The Bush administration claims they are rushing to deploy a limited missile defense system by 2004 because Korea may have a missile capable of reaching the U.S. with a nuclear warhead. But only a year or so ago the intelligence community reported that Korea was at least a decade or more away from building such a missile and even then it would be so inaccurate that it would be just as likely to hit South America as the United States.
Bush’s Iraqi war scheme forces us to speculate whether there really is a Korean nuclear missile threat. Or is this just another fabrication in order to gain support for a program with an ultimate price tag of a quarter trillion dollars that will greatly benefit a group of the President’s big campaign donors.
And there’s the rub. We can no longer trust the President.
Even if WMDs are suddenly discovered in Iraq, my first thought would be, are they real or did we plant them? Because a President who is willing to use convenient half-truths, selective information and lies to force a war in which thousands die is capable of just about anything. And as “Dubya” once attempted to say: “Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me.”
So when Bush tells us we need to cut down trees to prevent fires, I don’t believe him. And when he tries to tell us we are running out of energy and have to drill for oil in a pristine arctic wilderness, or that conservation doesn’t work, or that we need more arsenic in the water or that there is no global warming, I don’t believe him. And with the annual national budget hemorrhaging $400 billion in red ink, can we really believe the President when he tells us the latest round of tax cuts are a stimulus package? It gets worse.
During the mid-term elections, President Bush and the Republican Party wielded the so-called Iraqi threat to successfully savage Democratic candidates and to take control of both houses of Congress. But if the threat was in whole or part fabricated, the President may well have subverted the election process … for a second time.
Outside of the U.S., questions about the WMDs have lost the Bush administration, already a pariah with much of the world, whatever shred or credibility that may have remained. This will make it nearly impossible to create coalitions in the future and could negatively impact cooperation on terrorism. And with increasing anger being focused on the United States, how long before foreign consumers shun all American products and services.
During the election campaign George Bush promised to bring back honor to the Presidency. If it is proven that he manipulated our country into an unnecessary war killing thousands, he will have done far greater damage to the office and the world.
The only way President Bush will be capable of fulfilling his campaign promise will be to resign. (Ed Silverstein is a freelance writer living in Santa Monica.)
Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on July 9, 2003. Read the original PDF.