Skip to content

Western civilization didn’t begin

Published:

By Linda Piera-Avila Santa Monica

I read with utter disbelief your guest commentary by Thomas Bowden equating Columbus Day celebrations with victory over “Islamic totalitarianism.” (SMDP, Oct. 9-10, page 5). His essay is strewn with arrogant and Eurocentric racist remarks, despite his proclaimed standard of objectivity. How could Columbus have “discovered” a land that was already inhabited? The “spread of Western civilization... which flourished in the New World... served by highways, power plants, computers, and thousands of other life enhancing products” came at the hands of centuries of genocide of the native peoples, theft of their lands and resources and attempts to destroy their cultures. To say that the New World was “an inhospitable wilderness populated by frightened savages” is painfully offensive. The wilderness sustained life for those who understood it. Native peoples were and are members of diverse cultures whose wisdom and courage could help see our dominant culture through the many crises we are experiencing, if only we could listen.

Ishi, a California Yahi Indian who lived most of his life without European- American contact, said “The white man is clever, but not wise.” How true. Does industrial civilization engineering coupled with manifest destiny philosophy justify our greedy consumption of most of the world’s resources, including oil from Islamic countries, and reckless contribution to global warming? All the wealth and creature comforts we are accumulating will mean nothing when the planet is dead.

Benjamin Franklin, one of our “founding fathers,” spent time with the Iroquois confederation and returned home with the concept of a democratic society. Our staples of corn, beans and squash, among other foods, came from indigenous peoples. Gratitude and respect are owed native peoples, not the denigration espoused by Mr. Bowden. This same violent crusader mindset that would have us “prevail against the religious totalitarians” would also validate the desecration of native sacred sites and cemeteries in the name of “progress.” Failing to see other humans as just that is not the hallmark of an enlightened society.

Mr. Bowden, who claims that our reasoned civilization has shown mankind how to overcome war, argues in a contradictory fashion that we need to use force to prevail to defend our values of “individual rights and capitalism... and selfish pursuit of individual happiness.” He is morally and utterly certain of this. In light of recent corporate scandals and WTO abuses, it seems this is a recipe for immoral robber baron behavior instead.

A re-vamped equitable foreign policy based on fair trade should supplant Mr. Bowden’s promotion of military victory. Bowden ends his piece with the statement that “Western civilization is good according to an objective standard: Man’s life.” Which man’s life? Certainly not an indigenous man’s life, whose expectancy in many parts of the U.S. is about 49 years. Probably not a man or a woman in the Middle East or in a third world country, either. Exploitation of workers and resources in other countries surely does not enhance their quality of life. Going beyond “man’s life,” we also need to assess planetary health in any objective measure of our civilization. On that count, we may want to subjectively and humbly invoke the creator to forgive our destructively arrogant ways.

Originally published in the Santa Monica Daily Press print edition on October 15, 2004. Read the original PDF.

Comments

Sign in or become a SMDP member to join the conversation.

Sign in or Subscribe